Baileys Pudding Pies with Thin Mint Crust

Baileys Pudding Pies are EASY to make using chocolate pudding mix and whipped cream! They have a THIN MINT COOKIE crust and taste so much like Baileys.

I’m obsessed with Irish cream and after you try these pudding parfaits, I know you will be too!


baileys pudding in wine glass

Well hello and top of the mornin’ to ya! <<– That was my try at being Irish for half a second (although I actually think there is some Irish in there if I remember my results correctly).

Valentine’s Day is over, Mardi Gras is over, Easter is in 6 weeks but before the bunny visits we get to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day! Do you do anything fun on March 17? We don’t usually, except when Jordan was little we’d pretend the leprechaun messed up the house. Jordan was terrified of leprechauns for years; for the first two weeks of March she’d refuse to go anywhere in the house alone. I was so glad when they stopped building leprechaun traps and talking about them at school.

Now, Baileys isn’t really just a St. Patrick’s Day dessert, but in blog land and on Pinterest Irish cream recipes start popping up right about now. I actually love Baileys all year long, especially in my morning coffee when I’m traveling. That’s always what I use as my creamer on vacation if I don’t have to drive.

I think adding Baileys to chocolate pudding is probably one of the most genius things I’ve ever done. The first time I did it I made shots: thinned the pudding with milk and Irish cream to make a drink. Those are amazing and if you’re in the mood for a dessert cocktail, I highly recommend them.

However, if you want Baileys Pudding, try this recipe. It’s a more traditional pudding, plus I added whipped cream and CRUST to make Baileys Pudding Pies!

close up of baileys pudding pies in wine glass

I had the unfortunate experience to make this recipe at 10 in the morning. By noon I was craving Baileys for lunch but I had to go pick up Jordan from school so I couldn’t even enjoy them until after dinner. My entire kitchen smelled like the wonder that is Irish cream liqueur…and Thin Mint cookies.

The crust on this pie is made of Thin Mint cookies. Talk about a match made in heaven: Baileys and mint and chocolate. Perfection!!

The crunchy cookie mixed with the flavored pudding and whipped cream makes these the perfect dessert for any day of the year, but especially for St. Patrick’s Day!

Casserole dish with spoon holding up meatballs and cheese

Easy Meatball Casserole

Just 4 ingredients in this EASY Meatball Casserole recipe! It’s on the table in under 30 minutes and is the perfect weeknight meal! If you are looking for a recipe with a short prep...

stack of fruity pebble kristpie treats

Fruity Pebble Krispie Treats

Fruity Pebble Krispie Treats are the best kind of marshmallow cereal treat! Made with fruity pebbles and lots of marshmallows this recipe is gooey and sweet and the perfect rainbow treat! If you love...

stack of egg muffins

Easy Egg Muffins

Easy Egg Muffins are the perfect breakfast recipe! These are accidentally dairy-free and full of bacon and peppers. They freeze easy too, making breakfast easy for busy mornings. Not only are these egg muffins...

bowl of clam chowder with spoon inside

Mom’s Clam Chowder Soup

My Mom’s Clam Chowder Soup Recipe is the BEST ONE you’ll ever eat. This New England Clam Chowder is creamy and full of clams and potatoes and delicious flavor. I regularly crave this calm...

close up of top of red velvet cheesecake cake

Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Cake

Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Cake – this decadent cake recipe combines homemade red velvet cake with a cheesecake layer, chocolate cream cheese frosting, and OREOS! Basically, this cheesecake cake recipe is pure heaven! PIN...