Oreo Fluff Pie

Oreo Fluff Pie is an easy no bake pie recipe with Oreo crust and full of Oreos, pudding, and marshmallows! It’s a fluff salad in a pie crust!

Salad in pie crust. That means this is like vegetables, right? LOLOL


slice of oreo fluff pie on white plate

I know I announced this in my newsletter, so most of you have probably already heard about it. BUT…in case you don’t read my newsletter…I started another blog!

(I know, I’m nuts.)

Anyway, EasyGoodIdeas.com is going to be full of just that: easy good ideas. Sometimes they’ll be recipes, other ideas will include parties, printables, crafts, travel, and more. I’m using it as a creative outlet for things that I don’t post on Crazy for Crust. Sometimes stuff will overlap a little, like this Oreo Fluff Pie, but mostly the sites will be completely different from each other. I hope you’ll follow along!

One of my first posts over on EGI was Oreo Fluff Salad. I loved that recipe so much (we inhaled it within a few days) that I knew I wanted to turn it into a pie recipe. Oreos are always a hit on this site, no matter what I put them in (like…cake rolls or brownies or peanut butter cookies).

Oreo Fluff Salad is an easy recipe made with pudding, Oreos, whipped topping, and marshmallows, so I knew it would be the perfect thing to turn into a no-bake pie. That’s another thing that always does well here on Crazy for Crust: no bake recipes, especially pie.

A few years ago, I made a Skinny Oreo Cheesecake Dessert, which was basically weight watchers Oreo Fluff. This is like that recipe…but not weight watchers. Not even close!

And yes – I did try a bite of this pie. And it was GOOD. And I had to get it out of my house immediately or I would have eaten it all while binging Timeless.

overhead shot of Oreo Fluff Pie

When I was thinking about making this pie, I realized I had a leftover Oreo pie crust in my pantry. I’d bought two when I made my Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, just in case one broke. It was perfect: I didn’t feel like making an Oreo Crust from scratch, so I went the semi-homemade route. Feel free to make your own crust if you want!

The filling is just like you’d expect from a Fluff Salad recipe: pudding mixed with Cool Whip, Oreos, and marshmallows. The marshmallows and Oreos help give the pie body so it does hold together. This pie is very reminiscent of my Oreo Cheesecake recipe, except it’s not cheesecake. It’s salad in pie, remember?

pizza chicken on spoon in pan

Skillet Pizza Chicken Recipe

This EASY Skillet Pizza Chicken tastes just like pizza without the crust. Top chicken tenders with pizza toppings for an easy low-carb dinner. Use your favorite toppings to personalize this 30 minute chicken recipe! Easy...

sliced open unicorn cupcake with sprinkles inside

Unicorn Cupcakes

Unicorn Cupcakes are such a fun way to celebrate a birthday! Fill vanilla cupcakes with sprinkles and top with a swirled colorful frosting. Kids and adults will love this easy cupcake recipe! Have you...

pasta salad in wood bowl with dressing bottle

Mediterranean Chicken Pasta Salad

An easy creamy Mediterranean Chicken Pasta Salad is the perfect lunch or dinner for summer. Grilled chicken is mixed with a creamy parmesan garlic dressing for the perfect combination of Mediterranean flavors. Thanks to the...

close up of pink mimosa punch

Pink Mimosa Punch

Pink Mimosa Punch is the perfect drink for brunch! Make this easy mimosa recipe for one or make it a party punch! Pink champagne is mixed with orange juice, vodka, and fruit punch for...