Soft Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos

Did you know they make Peanut Butter Oreos? They are the bomb-diggity.

But these Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos are better. They’re soft-batch and HUGE.

It’s a match made in heaven!

PIN IT NOW to save for later!

Soft batch Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos recipe

You know what’s really strange? Twice in the past week people I know have come up to me and told me that their mother’s sister’s aunt’s daughter-in-law (or whatever) know my blog. That when they mention me and Crazy for Crust the person’s eyes get wide and they say “You know her??”

That’s just plain weird. People actually read this thing? Really?

Then they tell me the person loved my recipe for {fill in the blank} and I have a panic attack.

People are making my recipes? Really?

I still feel like I did 3 1/2 years ago – me, my computer, and my mom liking all my posts and being the first comment. My mom is my #1 fan, after all. Although my dad would probably argue that fact, so I’ll lump them together and say they’re BOTH my #1 fans.

Soft batch Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos - better than from the store!

My mom would love this recipe. It would have been a perfect recipe to give her for Mother’s Day.

{Notice my use of “would have”. Sorry mom – no homemade Oreos for you – today anyway.}

Mom always bought Oreos. I’d eat them right away, but my mom had a system. Day 1: Buy Oreos, open package, leave open. Day 3: Oreos are soft enough for eating.

Fresh Oreos are good, but stale Oreos get soft and are an entirely new kind of cookie. That’s why these would have been perfect for my Mom – they’re soft baked cookies. No crunch here!

The copycat Oreo cookie is a basic chocolate cookie. It’s made with Hershey’s Special Dark cocoa powder. That’s what gives it the “Oreo” flavor – the dark chocolate. They’re big cookies, made with a 2 tablespoon cookie scoop. You can make them smaller, if you’d like, but baking time will be affected.

The best part about this cookie recipe? No chilling! You’re welcome. You can now eat homemade Oreos even faster.

As much as I like regular Oreos, I loooooove the peanut butter ones. I mean, y’all know how addicted to peanut butter I am. The filling is a basic peanut butter buttercream. It’s really easy to make and the recipe makes a lot of frosting. I really hate running out of frosting so I always err on the side of too much. Ideas for using your extra frosting:

  • Make a double batch of cookies. One for you, one for your mom!
  • Make the cookies smaller and you’ll still have enough frosting.
  • Don’t make sandwich cookies, frost the tops instead.
  • Eat it with a spoon.
  • Eat it with a chocolate bar.
  • Eat it by squeezing the plastic bag into your mouth.

Homemade Oreos are super easy to make and I think I like them better than the real ones. Big statement, but true.

Plus, by making my own I can fill them with whatever I want. The ideas are abundant. More to come! (Edited to add: like lemon Oreos, coconut Oreos, or mint chip Oreos!)

Soft batch Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos - better than from the store!

I want to marry these cookies. In case you were wondering…

Did you make this recipe?

Soft Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos

These Soft Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos are better than from the store! They’re soft, huge, and FULL of peanut butter flavor, but they have that good old Oreo taste!

Ingredients:

Cookies

  • 1/3 cup Hershey’s Special Dark unsweetened cocoa powder (you can use regular unsweetened but they won’t be as “Oreo” like)
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 cup butter, softened
  • 2/3 cup brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 1 large egg

Filling

  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter
  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 3 cups powdered sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2-3 tablespoons heavy whipping cream

Directions:

  1. Preheat oven to 350°F. Line two cookie sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats.
  2. In a medium bowl, whisk together cocoa powder, baking soda, salt, and flour. Set aside.
  3. In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream butter and both sugars. Mix in egg and vanilla and mix until smooth. Add dry ingredients and mix until combined.
  4. Scoop 2 tablespoon sized balls of dough onto the cookie sheets. You will get about 15-17 cookies. (Alternately, you can use 1 tablespoon sized balls of dough and get twice as many cookies. Baking time will be less.)
  5. Bake for 8-9 minutes until they just lose their glossy sheen. Err on the side of underdone for these cookies; they taste better that way. Let cool completely before filling and making sandwiches.
  6. To make the filling: beat butter and peanut butter in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment. Mix in salt, then slowly beat in powdered sugar. Add vanilla, then 2 tablespoons of cream. Add a third tablespoon of cream as needed for the consistency you want. Note: this makes a lot of frosting, more than you need. It is enough frosting to fill the 2 tablespoon sized cookies OR the 1 tablespoon sized, plus extra. Filling can be frozen in an airtight container for up to one month.
  7. Once cookies are cooled, frost half with the frosting and sandwich with the other half. The best way to do this is to place your frosting in a gallon size ziploc bag and cut off one tip. Place a very large squeeze of frosting in the center of the bottom of a cookie, then press the top cookie on top, causing the frosting to spread to the edges.
All images and text ©. Please do not use my images without prior permission. If you want to republish this recipe, please re-write the recipe in your own words, or link back to this post for the recipe.

Hey, if you LOVE homemade Oreos, check out Homemade Brownie Oreos, Cookie Dough Oreos, or even use them to make Oreo Fluff.  Or what about HOMEMADE Stuffed NUTTER BUTTER Cookies?

Peanut Butter Oreo Trifle

Oreo Peanut Butter Trifle (5 of 5)w

 

Peanut Butter Covered Oreo Truffles

Peanut Butter Oreo Truffles (1 of 5)w

 

Reese’s Overload Cookies

Reeses-overload-cookies (4 of 6)w

Sweets from friends:
Homemade Cookie Dough Oreos by Something Swanky
Homemade Oreos by Sally’s Baking Addiction
Homemade Oreos with Strawberry Cream Cheese Filling by Eat Cake for Dinner

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

75 comments

  1. Those look so good! They look so soft and chocolaty 🙂

  2. Wow, these look amazing! I love the idea of homemade oreo’s! Especially loving the PB filling- super delicious recipe!

  3. Wow these are stunning! I’m usually not a huge fan of Oreos, but I think if they’re soft and filled with peanut buttery they’d be just perfect. 🙂

  4. Isn’t it funny the different traditions everyone has? I don’t think we have one for Oreos … eat all in one day? 😉 I’ll have to hide them to try the soft trick. Or I could just make these because you had me at soft batch and huge! Could there be anything better than a huge peanut butter Oreo??? Pinned!

  5. I love that these are soft and filled with peanut butter. That sounds so good! Have a great Mothers Day, Dorothy!

  6. Wow, you nailed these, Dorothy! I love PB (duh) and the fact that you did homemade PEANUT butter Oreos, well, you’re my hero 🙂 pinned

  7. Oh my gosh, I am in love with your pictures! These truly look like the ultimate cakey cookie! You can’t go wrong with oreos and peanut butter!

  8. soft oreo, check! bigger than Oreos, check! peanut butter oreos, check, check!!!

    These look fabulous! And of course people read your blog and make your recipes, silly! You have over 121,000 likes on FB! Your humility is humbling though. Makes me like you all that much more!

  9. Wow! I am almost speechless with all the oreo filling possibilities – mint of course, and food coloring for the holidays! I am seeing green and red at Christmas. But for every day – yes – peanut butter.

  10. Happy Mama’s day to you!! Your website is really wonderful. The pics are beautiful and you write so well. Thanks for something special each time!!
    Your Pittsburgh fan,
    Grandma Mary Brown

  11. These look fabulous! Hope you have a great Mother’s Day!

  12. love pb and chocolate. they look great!

  13. Do these need to be refrigerated? I’m looking for cookies to mail out of state.

  14. Thanks for the recipe – I love Oreos but don’t buy them because of the hydrogenated oil (tried Newman’s O’s, but they don’t taste as good). Happy Mother’s Day, Dorothy – Jordan is lucky to have a mother like you!

  15. Wow, these look fabulous! Great pix. And yes, I would love some. Guess I’ll have to make my own batch. 🙂

  16. You go girl!!! You are like a celebrity in food blog land 🙂 I love PB Oreos and yours look fantastic.

  17. Heavenly and awesome. I love these! And it’s so sweet about your mom. Great tribute for Mother’s Day!
    And Happy Mother’s Day to you!

  18. For starters, your photos are amazing in this post! They always are, but these just really pop. Really balanced composition (love the stacks!), bright lighting, pretty colors… And a super yummy subject! 😉 Your mom must’ve gotten used to how food bloggers bake something a week or two in advance before posting it. But I’m sure she’d love these! As for me? I’ll take the two parts separately. I almost always scrape the cream out of the centers and just eat the Oreo cookies, but I love PB enough that I wouldn’t want to toss that filling!

  19. Oh. My. Gosh. You went and made homemade peanut butter Oreos!!! I am in love!!!!! Happy Mother’s Day to you and your mom!! 🙂

  20. What a sweet relationship you have with your mom! So fun 🙂 Happy Mom’s Day to you! I hope you have a lovely day with your family.

  21. Dorothy, it’s 10:15 PM here and I am so hungry. Seeing these just put me over the top and I seriously need some sweets now. Love everything about these, the flavoring, the texture, you name it. So great.

  22. Oh man Oreos are the best and of course peanut butter is like the most amazing things ever. Combine the two and you have a super duper winner on your hands. Lovely!

  23. Girl, you are famous 🙂 It’s the best feeling when someone takes the time to make your recipe and then come back and tell you they loved it. It makes this whole blogging thing worth it. Love the thick peanut butter center. Pinned.

  24. Ooooooo…. these look amazing, Dorothy! 🙂 I love peanut butter & Oreos together. I may be guilty of spreading peanut butter on top of my Oreos at times…. but I like your idea MUCH better, lol!

  25. Dorothy that’s the most tempting cookie I’ve ever seen!

  26. This looks awesome! I love how the cookie part is puffier than actual oreos. I bet it tastes better too!

  27. Awww! Of course you’re a big deal-so sweet that your mom (and dad) is your #1 fan!!! I love that you made these for her and I def. approve! PB and Oreo’s are my fave combo and these look LUSCIOUS!

  28. Give me peanut butter and chocolate any day of the year! I loved hearing your thoughts about your number one fans. I know they’re proud.

  29. Oh boy! These look amazing. I’ve never had peanut butter oreos but I bet they are amazing. Will definitely have to try making these!

  30. I remember opening the Oreo pack and then leaving the pack open for a couple of days. Those soft Oreos are like a dream and now I won’t have to wait 3 whole days for them to go soft thanks to you and this delicious homemade peanut butter Oreo cookies! Who doesn’t like peanut butter!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :O <3 Goshh…. just looking at these cookies is making me H-U-N-G-R-Y!!! You know the kind of hunger that will not be satisfied with anything else but a particular food item! That's exactly how I'm feeling right now! WANT.THESE! Pinning! 😀

  31. I will be making these for sure!

    ~Ashley @ A Cute Angle
    acutelifestyle.blogspot.com

  32. So freakin’ fabulous! Love these!!

  33. Pingback: Love List | Chop & Central

  34. Heavenly!!! i love oreos and peanut butter. I can’t wait to make these!! Super delicious!! Thanks for the recipe!!

  35. My kind of cookies 🙂 Thanks for the recipe!

  36. The peanut butter Oreos are definitely one of my favorites, but I would absolutely love these more. I puffy heart love soft chewy cookies…hard ones just don’t do it for me. And filled with soft fluffy peanut butter frosting! Oh, boy, I would marry those cookies too!!!

  37. These look amazing, and sound awesome, Dorothy!

  38. My kids swear that I am the only person on earth who says the bomb diggety and that I made it up. I am so showing this to them tomorrow and rubbing it in their faces!

  39. YUM!! Thanks for another great recipe, Dorothy!

  40. These look amazing- I’m not sure I’d be able to share… 🙂

  41. Pingback: 14 reasons i might fail the sugar detox. » whatever

  42. Pingback: Soft Homemade Peanut Butter Oreos : Get Daily Recipes.com

  43. Pingback: 25 Fabulous Chocolate Peanut Butter Dessert Ideas - The Kid's Fun Review

  44. Pingback: Apple Slab Pie - Crazy for Crust

  45. Can you make this with a handmixer?

  46. I just made these last night for my friend’s birthday… I can’t wait to give them to her later today. I had to try one, of course, and they are delicious! I will definitely be making these again 🙂

  47. hi, I just stumbled across your blog through pinterest and oh my word I love it! I need to get baking and try some of your recipes. they may need a little tweeking as im in the uk so cant always get the same ingredients but I’m sure i’ll cope. thanks for sharing your kitchen with us.
    Suzanne x

  48. Oh my goodness! I think I have a baker’s crush on you, this looks amazing! And I WILL be making this as my next baking project.

  49. Does the butter in the filling need to be softened?

  50. Hey! I just discovered your amazing blog and I am totally amazed by the recipes! I can’t decide which one I wanna try first;)

    xxx from Germany
    Caprisserie

  51. Does the cream in the filling mean these need to be kept refrigerated once filled?

  52. Pingback: Soft Homemade Golden Oreos - Crazy for Crust

  53. I LOVE peanut butter oreos! love love love them. I was wondering if the peanut butter filling could be used for buckeyes. I love buckeyes but every recipe I try is too sweet (too much powdered sugar). The filling in the oreo is perfect. Your thoughts???

    • I think you could, if you leave out the heavy cream (or add less of it). You want a thicker paste-like texture so they’ll form balls and not be mushy. Try making the frosting w/o the cream and see if it comes together, or add just a teaspoon at a time until it just does. Let me know if it works!!

  54. Pingback: Buckeye Cookies - Baking Beauty

  55. Pingback: Yes Chef!!! | Jinnnnnnnnnnychoi

  56. OK Dorothy, I really enjoy your blog and recipes that I have tried always are soo good. These homemade oreo peanut butter filled babies are incredible. I am also a fan of your gooey brownies. I was wondering if you could guide me on making those gooey brownies with a peanut butter pretzel filling. Thanks and have a great day. Your Pittsburgh fan,Mary

    • That would be a great filling! You could mix some peanut butter (maybe 2 tablespoons) with the sweetened condensed milk and then sprinkle the pretzel pieces on when you add the SCM mixture!

  57. Pingback: Weekly Wrap-Up: An “off” week | A Little More Each Day

  58. just made these, they taste sinful.  You were right about the filling, made a TON! Halving that next time.  Love your site and recipes, keep ’em coming. 

  59. Oh my. I’ve had a hankering for something chocolatey and remembered I had these pinned. Yummy! I doubled the cookie recipe and made a single recipe of the filling and still had leftovers. (Perhaps I need to go back and double fill them 😊) With my 1.5 Tb cookie scoop I got forty cookies. So soft and tasty! The only thing I would change would be to add a little more salt to the filling, but that’s just me. I like my peanut butter salty. 😊 Thanks for sharing this yummy recipe!

  60. These look incredible and I will be making them for a baking competition at work! Quick question – when I put them onto the baking sheet, do I put them on a balls of cookie dough or flatten them at all? I just want to ensure that they all come out roughly the same size/shape so I can sandwich them. Thanks! 

    • If you scoop the balls of dough uniformly using a cookie scoop they should all end up the same size. You shouldn’t need to flatten, mine flattened fine on their own in the oven!

  61. I and everyone I’ve made these for loves these cookies! I would like to make them again but am hesitant because of the amount of filling waste. Can you scale back quantities for us?

    • You can always cut the filling in half. Without remaking the recipe, I wouldn’t know exact amounts. If you have leftover, you can use it for cupcakes or other sandwich cookies. Or freeze it!

  62. Soft Oreos sound amazing! I can’t wait to try these and thanks for linking to my soft butter butters 🙂

  63. Whhhaaat stale oreos makes them soft?? I have to try this out! Thanks for the link love friend 🙂

Leave a Comment »