This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, read my disclosure policy.

It’s that time of year: HOT. I want to eat only cold and frozen food, and popsicles fit that bill!

Lemon Pie Popsicles - an easy recipe made with Greek yogurt! Full of lemon flavor and a shortbread crust!

One of these days I will stop complaining about how hot it is. (When that day comes, you’ll know it’s winter.) Pretty much all I want to do right now is lay on top of the fan and eat frozen treats.

(The sad part is that, during the hottest summer I since we’ve lived in this area, I have to still use my oven. My kitchen remodel starts in about 8 weeks…so all my no-bake treats will be made in the fall. Oops!)

Last week my mom gave me a huge bag of lemons. By now you all know of my intense love of all lemon desserts, so getting a free bag of huge lemons is pretty much a rainbow sparkle day for me. I wanted to make lemon allthethings, but I had to narrow it down to just a few. The fact it was 109° outside helped me narrow it down even further: popsicles!

(To be truthful, I originally thought ICE CREAM, but I’ve already done that. Blog a few years and you tend to forget what you’ve made!)

And, because I love lemon pie (evidenced by recipes for tarts, bars, and a milkshake in my archives), turning pie into popsicles seemed like the thing to do.

Lemon Pie Popsicles made with McCormick food coloring and extract!

These popsicles are made using nonfat vanilla Greek yogurt. I added some fresh lemon juice and sugar but I really wanted to pump up the lemon flavor, so I added some McCormick Pure Lemon Extract. I love the taste it gives to any recipe; it reminds me of the Lemonades Girl Scout Cookies.

Turning pie into popsicles makes for a super easy recipe, one that your kids can even do all on their own. Jordan helped me mix in the extract and a little bit of McCormick yellow food coloring. I wanted the pops to look like lemon and taste like it!

Lemon Pie Popsicles (1 of 7)

You simply stir all the ingredients together and add them to your popsicle mold. I have a real popsicle mold that I love to use but it was already full in the freezer when I made these. (This is the popsicle mold I have.) I debated cleaning it out to make these but then I remembered that the little paper Dixie Bath Cups work perfectly for popsicles. You can use either mold!

Of course, no pie would be complete without a crust. I added some crushed shortbread cookies to top of the lemon mixture in the molds. After stirring the mixture up a little, most of the crumbs freeze on top to give your popsicle a crust…just like a pie.

A few notes about the recipe:

  • You can use regular, lowfat, or nonfat yogurt. I used Greek style, but feel free to use a regular yogurt if you prefer. I suggest using the vanilla or you might need to add more sugar.
  • I used granulated sugar to sweeten. The lemon juice adds a fresh tartness to the popsicle, but you need a little more sweet. 1/2 cup of sugar was perfect for me, but taste test to make sure you like it okay.
  • Feel free to substitute a sugar-free sweetener for the sugar, but beware you’ll most likely need less than 1/2 cup.
  • You can use popsicle sticks or cute straws as your stick. I am a hoarder of straws and I thought they looked pretty with the yellow of the popsicle. I get my colorful straws on Etsy (just search paper straws).

Lemon Pie Popsicles made with Greek yogurt! An easy recipe everyone will love for summer!

This Lemon Pie Popsicle recipe will make anyone happy this summer, because it’s so easy. It’s also good, because it’s pie on a stick. These are going to get me through summer…I hope!

Lemon pie popsicle tipped on its side with more popsicles in the background

Lemon Pie Popsicles

No ratings yet
These Lemon Pie Popsicles are the perfect way to have your pie in a frozen treat! Made healthier using Greek yogurt, these pie pops are full of lemon flavor from fresh lemon juice and extract and even have a shortbread crust!
Yield 8


  • 2 cups nonfat vanilla Greek yogurt regular yogurt may be substituted
  • 3 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar you can also use a sweetener, but you’ll need less
  • 1/4 teaspoon McCormick pure lemon extract
  • 2-3 drops McCormick yellow food coloring
  • 2-3 shortbread cookies crushed (or use Nilla Wafers or Golden Oreos)


  • Stir yogurt, lemon juice, sugar, extract, and food coloring in a medium bowl using a spatula or wooden spoon.
  • Scoop equal amounts of lemon mixture into paper dixie cups or popsicle molds. Mine filled 8 dixie cups about 2/3 full.
  • Sprinkle about 2 teaspoons of cookie crumbs on top of the yogurt mixture. Use a toothpick or popsicle stick to stir gently. Pack what crumbs are left on top.
  • Insert sticks or colorful straws. Freeze for at least 4 hours or overnight. (It’s easiest to freeze the dixie cups if they’re sitting on a cookie sheet.) Remove paper or remove popsicles from molds and enjoy!
Nutritional information not guaranteed to be accurate

Click here to see the complete list of Lemon Recipes!

Lemon Pie Milkshake

Lemon Pie Milkshake (1 of 5)

No Bake Golden Oreo Lemon Dessert

Lemon Dessert (3 of 6)w

Skinny Lemon Ice Cream

Skinny Lemon Ice Cream 3 words

Sweets from friends:
Banana Nutella Fudgsicles by The Viet Vegan
50 Popsicle Recipes at Chocolate, Chocolate, and More
Strawberry Jam Yogurt Pops by Very Culinary

This post is sponsored by McCormick as part of my ongoing ambassadorship with them. All opinions are 100% my own and I thank you for helping me support the brands I love that make Crazy for Crust possible!

Last Updated on May 15, 2019

Dorothy Kern

Welcome to Crazy for Crust, where I share recipes that are sometimes crazy, often with a crust, and always served with a slice of life.

Learn to Bake in 4 Days!
Get my tips, tricks and recipes to take your baking to the next level for FREE!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating


  1. The perfect tiny treat! I love lemon recipes – they’re so refreshing! Looking forward to adding this to my healthy dessert rotation because they’re made with yogurt! 🙂

  2. I little bit of lemon zest in these would make them over the top amazing!   Yummy! 

    I need to go get some (dairy free) yogurt. 🙂

  3. This is a beautiful combination of pie and a frozen dessert. I love how you didn”t leave out the pie crust!

  4. Those popsicles look SO delicious, Dorothy! Super refreshing for summertime – pinned!! 🙂