This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, read my disclosure policy.

Move over Oreo Truffles, there’s a new candy in town: Taffy Truffles, made out of Mother’s Taffy Cookies!

Taffy Truffles cut in half sitting on top of a wooden board

Can we talk for a minute about towels? Because it has so much to do with these truffles.

{I’m lying. It doesn’t. I just want to vent.}

Why is it so hard for a kid to hang up a wet towel? WHY?

Step one: Dry off.

Step two: Hang up towel on hook, yes, hook, that your parents provide for you so you didn’t have to hang it on a towel bar because obviously using a towel bar is for highly intelligent educated adults.

Step three: Throw towel on floor wherever you dry off: bathroom, hallway, bedroom, garage.

Step four: Mom cleans room and finds dry crunchy towels buried in piles of “I put it away” laundry.

WHY? Is it really that hard to hang it on a hook?


Whew, sorry. Had to get that off my chest. Now, truffles.

taffy truffles cut in half collage

Several years ago my mother-in-law reintroduced me to Mother’s Taffy Cookies. And by reintroduced I mean I ate an entire package in a weekend visit. Since then I realized that I must stay on the wagon – I can’t even buy them.

As it is, you’ll notice this recipe calls for 8 Taffy Cookies. Why 8? Why not 10? Because in the two days it took me to get to this recipe after buying them there were only 10 left in the package and I needed two for props.

It’s hard to describe what the flavor even is, except that it’s got coconut in it. The cookie is crunchy and tastes like brown sugar and toasted coconut. The filling is sweet and creamy, like Oreo filling, but better. The front of the package boasts “Dulce de Leche” but, honestly, all I get is coconut.

Oreo Truffles are all the rage these days and I’ve made my share. I’ve covered them with peanut butter and made them into s’mores. And about a year ago I bought a bag of these Taffy Cookies to make Taffy Truffles out of them but a few days went by and I ran out.

#addicted #ontheTaffyCookieWagon

Anyway, these are the same thing as an Oreo Truffle, but made with a different cookie. This same method works with 99% of cookies, BTW. You just have to adjust the amount of cream cheese you use depending on the filling or dryness of the cookie itself.

This recipe has 4 ingredients and comes together in literally minutes. If you love Taffy Cookies, you’ll love these more. They have all the flavor but are soft and sweet like a truffle.

There are so many recipes I want to make with these cookies but I know if I buy a pack I run the risk of never actually making a recipe with them. So buyer beware. 🙂

Moral of the story: go buy these cookies, and make these truffles. If you love Oreos truffles but you also love coconut, I guarantee you’ll LOVE these.

taffy truffle cut in half overhead shot

Make yourself a batch and then go pick up towels. It’s what I did.

Taffy Truffles sitting on top of a wooden board

Taffy Truffles

No ratings yet


  • 8 Taffy Cookies Mother’s brand
  • 2 ounces cream cheese regular or low-fat
  • 6-8 ounces Candiquik vanilla or chocolate or similar product (you can also use baking chocolate)
  • Sprinkles or toasted coconut for topping
Save this recipe!
Get this sent to your inbox, plus get new recipes from us every week!


  • Grind the cookies and cream cheese in a food processor until a ball forms. Scoop 1 tablespoon sized scoops of the mixture and roll into balls. Place on a wax paper lined cookie sheet and chill for 30 minutes.
  • When ready to dip, melt your candy according to package directions. (Use these helpful tips for dipping.) Dip each truffle, tapping off the excess and place back on your wax paper lined cookie sheet. Top with sprinkles or toasted coconut for topping. Chill until set.
Nutritional information not guaranteed to be accurate

S’more Oreo Truffles

Coconut Cream Truffles

Maple Walnut Truffles

Tutorial: How To Dip Candy & Truffles without tears

Sweets from friends:
Red Velvet Truffle Bark by Something Swanky
Circus Animal Cookie Dough Truffle Bars by Beyond Frosting
Thin Mint Truffle Bark by Wine & Glue

Last Updated on May 13, 2020

Dorothy Kern

Welcome to Crazy for Crust, where I share recipes that are sometimes crazy, often with a crust, and always served with a slice of life.

Learn to Bake in 4 Days!
Get my tips, tricks and recipes to take your baking to the next level for FREE!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating


  1. So yummy! Gonna try this truffles soon! It’s a long time from the last time I have one. Thank you for the recipe!

  2. I totally hear ya on the kids not hanging up their towels! Someday they’ll have kids of their own who will do it to them! Mwahaha! πŸ˜‰ These truffles would totally disappear in my house! They look fantastic!

  3. Aargh, the towels – the hubs does that and drives me bonkers haha! But oh my gosh, these truffles!!! You make the prettiest truffles and these taffy cookies sound amazing! Pinning πŸ™‚

  4. I’ve never heard of these cookies before! I live in VA. Do you suppose they only sell them on the west coast?? How can I get these yummy cookies? I want to make these truffles NOW!!! Thanks for all your great recipes!

  5. OMG, those are the best cookies ever! Those and English Tea. Thank you for sharing this recipe as I will be making them this weekend.