Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes

They might be plain vanilla, but these Vanilla Cupcakes are perfect, and are perfectly complimented with the vanilla buttercream and whipped cream filling.

Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes - the best homemade ones I've ever had, and super vanilla-y! | | #cupcake

I know. A plain vanilla cupcake? Like…what?

If we’re being 100% honest with each other…I prefer a vanilla cupcake. A simple, rich vanilla cupcake and a super vanilla-y frosting. I’ll take this kind of cupcake over chocolate, peanut butter, or any other flavor.

As crazy as I like to bake, as much as I love to make rich food, there’s something about the simple flavor of vanilla. I love it! And these Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes totally deliver.

Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes - the best homemade ones I've ever had, and super vanilla-y! | | #cupcake

As you probably know, last weekend was my birthday. I was out of town (at the Duncan Hines Test Kitchen, so much more on that coming soon) so the family and I celebrated my birthday early. I had a full fake birthday, complete with presents, a movie, and dinner.

And cupcakes.

Of course, Jordan wanted to make me some cupcakes. Mel, on the other hand, wasn’t so sure about helping her do that. So we compromised – I made the cupcakes and frosting and then they decorated them for me. I left out the sprinkles, candies, and mini marshmallows and left for the gym, certain my kitchen floor would be a myriad of colors when I returned.

{It wasn’t – my husband remembered to sweep!}

birthday photo

Now, I just had to include this photo. One, because it shows how Jordan decorated my cupcake. And two, because this photo speaks volumes about my life right now. Can you see what I mean?

I’m blowing out the candles on my birthday cupcake, and I’m holding my phone. #imaddicted #iphoneanonymousneeded

Also…I need a prop cabinet in the worst way. #OMG #prophoarder {Why yes, that is a used Biscoff coffee cup from my trip to SF. Everyone keeps used coffee cups for props, right?}

{And, BTW, have you tried out the Picmonkey effects for people? Normally I just edit food photos. Man, I’m editing every single photo of me from now on.}

These Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes are just that – perfect. Normally I avoid homemade vanilla cupcakes because they’re always to dry, tough, delicate, hard, etc. Box mixes are just so easy – and they’re always perfect. But, since I don’t have a vanilla cupcake recipe here, I wanted to try my hand at it.

Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes - the best homemade ones I've ever had, and super vanilla-y! | | #cupcake

A few notes about the recipe:

  • It uses all-purpose flour. Many recipes call for cake flour. That’s all well and good, but I don’t want to buy special flour. This makes these easier, and more accessible for the regular home cook.
  • But, it does include unsalted butter. All the recipes I looked at specified unsalted. I normally use salted butter, because it’s what I’ve always bought and eaten. However, if every single cupcake recipe I find uses unsalted, then I better go with the masses!
  • In the past I’ve used butter in cupcakes and they’ve been dry and tough. Oil often makes them too weak to stand up to a load of frosting. So I remembered a tip (from, I believe, my friend Sally) to use melted butter. It made a huge difference!
  • The cupcakes make about 14. So…sorry you have to use two pans. But they’re worth it. :)
  • Let’s talk vanilla. Extract is easiest, I know. Vanilla beans are the best – but at $8 a pop, they really aren’t doable for me (and I never remember to order them online). Instead, I use Vanilla Bean Paste. I love the vanilla flavor it puts into things, and you still get those little black dots all over the cupcake and frosting from the beans.

The frosting is my favorite too – a pure vanilla frosting. I whip butter with powdered sugar, add more vanilla bean paste, and some heavy cream to get it to the texture I like for frosting. It’s all sweet and vanilla-y and perfect! This frosting would be awesome on chocolate cupcakes too. And the cupcakes would be awesome with chocolate frosting, or even caramel frosting!

I also filled these with a simple whipped cream, sweetened with powdered sugar and, you guessed it, more vanilla bean paste. I cannot get enough of that stuff! The filling is a total option, but if you want to add a little something extra, go for it.

These really are triple vanilla cupcakes – and totally perfect! They’re tender without collapsing, they’re soft and not dry, and they stand up to a huge dollop of frosting (because really, is there any other way to frost?)

Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes - the best homemade ones I've ever had, and super vanilla-y! | | #cupcake

My mouth is watering for more. Vanilla is one of my favorite flavors…especially in Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes!

Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes

Yield: About 14 cupcakes

Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes


    For the cupcakes:
  • 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1 stick unsalted butter, melted
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1 tablespoon vanilla bean paste
  • 3/4 cup buttermilk (or combine 3/4 cup milk + 1 teaspoon white vinegar and let sit for 5 minutes)
  • For the filling:
  • 1/2 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 2 tablespoons powdered sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon vanilla bean paste
  • 1/2 teaspoon butter extract
  • For the frosting:
  • 2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 5 1/2 cups powdered sugar
  • 1 tablespoon vanilla bean paste
  • 1-2 tablespoons heavy whipping cream


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Line cupcake tins with liners (makes 12-15).
  2. Whisk flour, baking powder, and salt in a medium bowl.
  3. Add melted butter to a large bowl and mix in sugar with a hand mixer for 30 seconds until thick and yellow. Add eggs one at at time, beating after each addition. Beat in vanilla bean paste.
  4. Add the flour mixture and buttermilk alternately, starting and ending with the flour. Don’t over mix! Divide batter among liners, filling 2/3 full. Bake for 15-20 minutes until a toothpick comes out clean. (Mine took less than 20, so check at 15!) Cool completely before frosting!
  5. To make the filling: beat heavy cream and powdered sugar until stiff peaks form. Whisk in both extracts.
  6. To make the frosting: Beat butter until creamy. Beat in salt and 1 cup of powdered sugar at a time until it’s all added. Beat in vanilla bean paste and 1 tablespoon of heavy whipping cream. Add more cream as needed for desired consistency.
  7. To fill cupcakes: you can either fill a pastry bag fitted with a round tip and poke it into the center of the cupcake to fill, or you can carefully cut out a hole in the center and fill with a spoon.
  8. Frost cupcakes by placing frosting in a pastry bag. I like the 1M tip, it gives pretty swirls. Add sprinkles for fun!
  9. Note: you can make the frosting the day before, but let it come to room temperature before using.
  10. Find vanilla bean paste on amazon, or at stores like William's-Sonoma or Sur la Table.


No need to fill the cupcakes, I just wanted a little extra. These cupcakes would be great with chocolate frosting, and the vanilla buttercream would be good with any flavor cupcake!

If you make the frosting alone, without the cupcakes, you can use salted butter if that's what you have on hand. Just leave out the salt!

Cupcake Recipe slightly adapted from Martha Stewart.

Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin

Mint Chip Milkshake Cupcakes

mint-chocolate-milkshake-cupcakes (3 of 7)w

Almond Cupcakes with Caramel Frosting

almond-cupcakes-caramel-frosting (2 of 4)w

The BEST Chocolate Cupcakes

best-chocolate-cupcakes (7 of 9)

Sweets from friends:
Root Beer Float Cupcakes by Dip it in Chocolate
Seven Layer Bar Cupcakes by The Domestic Rebel
Original Karamelgebäck Creme Cupcakes by Java Cupcake
Monster Cookie Dough Cupcakes by Something Swanky


 Subscribe via email and have sugar delivered straight to your inbox!

This post may be linked to: Chef in TrainingLil’ LunaChic-and-CraftyI’m Lovin’ it FridaysWeekend PotluckWeekend Wrap Up Partyand all of these too!


  1. They’re tender without collapsing, they’re soft and not dry, and they stand up to a huge dollop of frosting = THAT IS SUCCESS!!

    Wow, thanks for doing all the legwork so I dont have to. About 6 mos ago i wanted to post some more ‘classics’ to my site, like a basic vanilla cupcake and got very close to making some and then my book got too busy and I let this project slip but I had like 5 recipes I wanted to test. Now, I can just make yours :)

    • I always have trepidation about adding these to my site, because of the basic-ness. But they’re so good!

    • Katherine says:

      These were seriously gross…
      My 5 year old loves anything with sugar (obviously, he’s five) and he ate half of one and got a tummy ache.
      My husband loved them but had stomach problems in the morning.
      I wasted a few sticks of butter and have found, hands down, the worst recipe I’ve tried online.

      • I’m sorry you feel that way Katherine. Did you follow the recipe exactly? I have made these several times with success and so have many of my readers. Possibly buttercream is too sweet for your family? Buttercream such as this is for sure very sweet, and if you’re used to something less sweet these might be too rich. Everyone has a taste preference, so I understand if you don’t like them. Just for other reader sakes, please know that these have never caused me, or anyone I’ve known to eat them, tummy trouble.

  2. An awesome vanilla cupcake is an essential to me! I’ve yet to find one that I’d call “perfect”. I’m definitely going to try yours! They look and sound delicious! :)
    Lindsay @ Life, Love and Sugar recently posted..Cinnamon Apple Oatmeal Cheesecake Cookie BarsMy Profile

  3. That is so sweet that they made you cupcakes!! These look amazing! I never heard of vanilla bean paste before but I am so going to look for it now. I do not buy vanilla beans either because they are just not in the budget!!
    Nancy P.@thebittersideofsweet recently posted..Pumpkin Spice Marshmallow Popcorn BallsMy Profile

  4. I love the vanilla bean dots everywhere !!!!! :)
    Maggie @Maggiecooks recently posted..No-bake cheesecakeMy Profile

  5. Seriously, vanilla cupcakes get a bad rap. When they’re real, and vanilla-ey, like these, they are just heaven!
    Nora (Buttercream Fanatic) recently posted..Chocolate Caramel Cheesecake [a guest post from monica and caroline of Pass the Cocoa]My Profile

  6. Yum! Yum! Yum! I love vanilla cupcakes!
    Ida recently posted..MIAMI: I #LOVETHISCITY #MC!My Profile

  7. Vanilla vanilla is my favorite! I was on a mission to make the perfect vanilla cake for my daughter’s first birthday! The party has passed, but I better try these….for next year! Vanilla bean paste saved my life!
    Alex recently posted..Apple and Carrot MuffinsMy Profile

  8. Lovely! Although I do love cupcakes, I’ve got to admit that I am really all about the frosting! :)
    Tonia@thegunnysack recently posted..Caramel Apple In A JarMy Profile

  9. Oh my gosh these do look perfect! So fun seeing you this weekend, hope it was a great birthday!

  10. These are truly perfect!! I love a simple vanilla cupcake too and will pick it any day over chocolate. That little bit of whip cream in the center is the perfect touch :). Vanilla bean paste = awesome!!!
    PS: Is there an iPhone anonymous?? I would like to check myself in please!
    Zainab @ Blahnik Baker recently posted..Pumpkin Bundt Cake with Bourbon Cream Cheese FrostingMy Profile

  11. Good ole’ vanilla cupcakes are one of my favs and what a sweet gift from your daughter! I can relate to prop hoarding! I go to garage sales every weekend….I have an entire room full of props!

    Marti recently posted..SEW Organized! {Guest Features}My Profile

  12. So pretty :) Happy late birthday!
    Jenn recently posted..Baked Italian SandwichMy Profile

  13. LoverOfAnythingChocolate says:

    These look so yummy and perfect! I don’t buy vanilla bean paste, and they don’t really sell it around here, and it has alcohol/bourbon in it, which I don’t drink, so what do I do?????

    Your photography is awesome!

  14. Love vanilla! Glad you had a good bday and trip :)
    Laura @ Lauras Baking Talent recently posted..Apple ChipsMy Profile

  15. these are without a doubt the best cupcakes i have ever seen! i LOVE vanilla – and they are gorgeous! that cream looks TDF Jordan did an excellent job on yours :)
    Heather @ French Press recently posted..Apple and Cinnamon Fruit LeatherMy Profile

  16. Oh Dorothy! They certainly DO look perfect! There is nothign quite like a perfect vanilla cupcake. It will take you far in life. It’s a great “base” for SO many creative recipes. I have no doubt that you can turn these cupcakes into a single layer cake, too. And yes, melted butter is my jam. Love using it in vanilla cupcake recipes.

    LOVING the sprinkles and cream filling! Sometimes it’s hard to shoot all white cupcakes, all white frosting, and all white filling but your photoshoot is gorgeous.
    sally @ sallys baking addiction recently posted..Apple Spice Quinoa Granola.My Profile

  17. I am totally in love with vanilla bean paste, it is so amazing! Do you think these cupcakes need to be refrigerated with the whipped cream filling?
    Julianne @ Beyond Frosting recently posted..Oatmeal Pumpkin Spice Pudding CookiesMy Profile

  18. another delicious recipe! Great pic too, love the jewelry!

  19. These look great! I don’t think there’s anything better than a good vanilla cupcake. I especially love that these ones are filled, most of the other recipes I’ve seen online don’t have that additional element.
    Rebecca @ Exploits of a Dorm Room Baker recently posted..Apple Oatmeal CookiesMy Profile

  20. Dorothy, these are simply stunning! I have yet to have the perfect vanilla cupcake, but no I know which recipe to make to get them! The cake, the filling and the frosting are just incredible! I normally use vanilla beans, but have been wanting to try vanilla bean paste. Did you get it online? I think I need to head to amazon and find some!

    Still cannot get over your photos and the cute sprinkles!
    Tieghan recently posted..Peanut Butter Cup Cookies & Cream Salted Caramel Popcorn BarsMy Profile

  21. Awww Dorothy, they turned out beautifully!! I’m so glad our little lunch date didn’t take too much time away from your baking. ;) And that is SO sweet that Mel and Jordan decorated them (and cleaned up the kitchen)! Also 100% adorable that you celebrated your birthday early. LOVE it!! And you’re right, vanilla cupcakes are actually pretty hard to perfect. Your batch looks and sounds amazing!
    Amy recently posted..Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough CheesecakeMy Profile

  22. I think vanilla cupcakes are my favorite kind of cupcake, even though I am usually a chocolate person! Happy belated birthday, sounds like you had lots of fun :)
    Kristi @ My San Francisco Kitchen recently posted..Greek PizzaMy Profile

  23. Everyone who bakes needs this recipe! Gorgeous vanilla cupcakes, girl. Thanks for sharing! Pinning!

  24. Happy belated birthday! I’m seriously a sucker for vanilla cupcakes so this is perfect!!
    Rachel @ Baked by Rachel recently posted..Slow Cooker Pulled Pork with Apples and OnionsMy Profile

  25. Happy Belated Birthday!!
    I love the vanilla bean bits in the frosting! Love the simple yet beautiful cupcakes!
    Angie | Big Bears Wife recently posted..Three Cheese Loaded Red Skin Mashed Potatoes #BGFarmTourMy Profile

  26. You look so cute in your bday pic (I have long loved the people editors on picmonkey and-formerly-picnik)!

    I love a good vanilla cupcake myself and yours look like THE BEST!

  27. I prefer vanilla any day too!! I would be in some serious trouble if these were in my household!! These look sooooo good!!
    Happy Belated Birthday!!
    tahnycooks recently posted..Caramelized Onion, Fig and Goat Cheese Quiche with an Olive Oil Herbed CrustMy Profile

  28. I am a chocolate gal. I always go for chocolate….except when it comes to cupcakes. For some reason vanilla just seems better. These look perfect!
    Emily @ Life on Food recently posted..maple cinnamon granolaMy Profile

  29. Wow sometimes you can’t beat “plain” old vanilla cupcakes. THESE LOOK FREAKIN FANTASTIC!
    Julie @ Julie’s Eats & Treats recently posted..Cinnamon Chip Pumpkin Cookies #OXOGoodCookieMy Profile

  30. Everything about this post = yes! These cupcakes; wow girl, you did it! These are PERFECT. Thanks for your helpful notes! And your pictures are stunning. Like, drop dead gorgeous. I saw them on Pinterest and was like, wow, now those are some cupcakes! Haha, and yes, I have tried the effects in Picmonkey and no, I’m not saying whether I use them all the time or not:)
    Mary Frances @ The Sweet {Tooth} Life recently posted..Things I’m Loving This Week {#2}My Profile

  31. I could use one right now!
    Dina recently posted..Save Village Halloween Parade!My Profile

  32. Sometimes a really lovely, basic dessert is best….with coffee. Thanks for sharing and a belated Happy Birthday to you! Looking forward to hearing about the Duncan Hines experience!
    Melissa recently posted..Peach Pie with my GrandparentsMy Profile

  33. Hope you had a happy birthday! These cupcakes look wonderful! My husband is a huge vanilla cupcake fan, so I am sure he will love these!
    Stephanie @ Macaroni and Cheesecake recently posted..Chicken Enchilada SkilletMy Profile

  34. Sometimes you just need the perfect vanilla cupcake! Love that filling that you added. PS I may or may not be glued to my phone as well…

  35. That seals the deal, we were destined to be BFF’s. I ALWAYS prefer a plain vanilla cupcake. We LOVE trying out cupcake shops everywhere we go, and I always end up liking the plain vanilla best. I don’t know what it is about, but it’s awesome! I have a recipe that I love too, but I am definitely going to try this one. I totally know what you mean about your phone too. My kids say I need it more than air to survive. LOL! It is my lifeline. I swear I don’t know how I ever survived a doctors visit, school carpool line, etc without it. I currently have an iPhone 5 but am waiting on my new Android to arrive. A little nervous but really excited too! :)
    Shari @ Shari Blogs recently posted..Cinnamon Sugar CookiesMy Profile

  36. I have way too many things to say about this post! First, my prop hoarding puts yours to shame in a weird and disgusting, also sort of overwhelming, way. Two, I totally noticed the phone right away! #awesome Three, my profile picture had the crap edited out of it! Lol!! These cupcakes look amazing!! I also prefer a vanilla cupcake! Pinning!
    Lisa @ Wine & Glue recently posted..Cookie Butter Butterscotch FudgeMy Profile

  37. I will never turn down a fantastic vanilla cupcake! I have found many white cake recipes that seemed promising but do turn out dry and crumbly, which always disappoints me since I would love to make a great vanilla cupcake/cake for my (very picky) mom. These sound great though–I will definitely give them a shot, if you’re behind these. Thanks!
    Ala recently posted..Monday Morning Mocha ‘n Chocolate CheesecakesMy Profile

  38. I don’t think vanilla is plain at all. It’s one of my favorite flavors. I only ever have unsalted butter in my house because I use it mainly for baking. If you want it on your toast, you have to add your own salt. These cupcakes look beautiful. I can’t wait to try them.
    Renee @ Awesome on $20 recently posted..My Awesome Trip to Duncan HinesMy Profile

  39. Sometimes basic is best, in this case definitely! They look gorgeous, vanilla cupcakes are so hard to make at home, if I need vanilla I almost always go for a box, I hate wasting and I wont use the cupcakes unless they are perfect. Yours do look perfect. Love the filling and frosting and the fluffiness of the cake. Need this in my life stat!!
    Elizabeth @ Confessions of a Baking Queen recently posted..Oat Flour Pumpkin BreadMy Profile

  40. My favorite cake/cupcake/ice cream/just about anything is plain old vanilla. These look perfect, Dorothy!
    Ashley @ Kitchen Meets Girl recently posted..Wake Up WednesdaysMy Profile

  41. Jessica K says:

    I’m pretty sure that was the best vanilla frosting I have ever made. I had no idea the difference that using vanilla bean paste made over extract

  42. Hi there! I come from Greece which ( apart from other things…) means that some of the terminology that you are using is not really familiar to me. When you are saying “1stick butter or unsalted butter” what do you mean in terms of weight?

  43. I just made these tonight and they are the best vanilla cupcakes I have ever eaten! Thank you for sharing this recipe, it’s going to be a household cupcake recipe for us :)

  44. I don’t even know what happened with these… My batter was VERY liquidy… And so greasy they slipped through and destroyed their liners!!! I substituted vanilla extract for paste.. Could that be a problem? Otherwise., the taste of the destroyed cupcakes was fine.. But everything else was horrible!!! :(

    • I’m so sorry Rebecca! I’ve had others make them and report success, so I’m tying to figure out what might have gone wrong. I doubt the extract for paste would make that much of a difference. Were there any other substitutions? I know my batter was thin (not thick like brownie batter, but thin like cake mix cake batter). Are your liners any sort of specialty liner?

  45. hi! is it ok to substitute all purpose flour with cake flour?

  46. Just found your recipe this morning and wanted to give it a try, but found I was short of eggs (decided to double the recipe). Many claim to have the “perfect Vanilla Cupcake” recipe and I am unhappy with the results from my oven. Not with yours! I wish I had the ingredients to make it exactly as you developed, but I did need to omit the filling and substituted 1/4 cup vegetable oil for missing egg. This is a very good recipe. I would encourge others to give it a try and post any substitutions or changes made and the results.

  47. I stumbled across this recipe whilst trying to occupy my boredom and satisfy my sweet tooth simotaneously. Now I’m no baking genious, and I didn’t have butter on hand. But, I did have a tub of margarine, so I used that. Needless to say, the cupcakes did not turn out how they should have. But, they came out sort of pancake-like, so I topped them with rasberry jam and served them hot, and they’re delicious! Just thought I’d share my happy accident with all you guys out there! Can’t wait to try this recipe the way it was intended, but nonetheless, thank you for posting this!

  48. I made these twice within a week. The first time I tried to do everything exactly as noted and the cupcakes came out beautifully! My family loved them. Then I made a second batch because I had extra frosting but unfortunately, those didn’t come out as great. They took longer to bake than the recommended time and even then didn’t seem completely done in the middle. I cut the recipe in half so as to not have too many; do you think that was the issue? I have a scale and was able to weigh the ingredients but I’m wondering if the amount of egg was the issue. At any rate I’ll be making them again today for New Years!

    • That could be it Vanessa – cutting 3 eggs in half can change the outcome. I’ve never halved the recipe, so I’m not sure how that would turn out. If you make a full batch, they do freeze well! :) I’m glad the first batch turned out good!

      • Hi Dorothy, thanks for your response. I made another full batch and they turned out great, so I’m sure the problem had something to do with halving the recipe (maybe I overbeat the batter since there was less of it?)I did freeze a couple this time around; thank you for the tip and for posting this great recipe.

  49. I made these last sunday and they were terrific! They were gone by the next day. My family loved them. I had never heard of vanilla bean paste and it was my first time using it. I loved it. Definitely going to be using it more.

  50. I can’t wait to make these for my son’s first birthday! I do have a quick question for you…if I were to make this into a cake (rather than cupcakes), would I have to change anything in the recipe? I imagine I would have to adjust the cooking time, but I was wondering if I would need to change anything else.

    • I think it would work okay, with adjusted baking time. But it only makes about 12-14 cupcakes, so it’s not a full 9×13 cake. It’s probably more of one 9″ round (possibly would fit good in a 9″ round by 3″ high or a 9″ square). Let me know how it turns out!

  51. Ashley B. says:

    I made these yesterday and they were the perfect cake for my Boston cream pie cupcakes! The only thing I changed was substituting some of the AP flour with cake flour. (I just like the taste and texture it gives.) Thanks for a great basic recipe!

    • Awesome! I’m glad you liked them Ashley!

    • How is everyone storing these cupcakes? I wanted to make them a day ahead for my daughter’s baptism but wanted to know if they would store good refrigerated. Thanks in advance for your help!

      • You can chill them over night loosely covered or in a Tupperware container. You can make the cupcakes and frosting ahead of time and frost before serving if you’re worried about storing frosted cupcakes. Just make sure to let the frosting come to room temperature before frosting (and you may need to add a touch more cream to smooth it out). They can both also be frozen (unfrosted) if needed! Enjoy!

  52. I usually add cream cheese to my frosting. I am wondering if you find its easier to decorate the cupcakes with frosting that doesn’t have cream cheese added. I often find the frosting “melts” on me as I am decorating the cupcakes and wonder if its because of the cheese. I should just try without it but its so good I don’t ever leave it out :)

    • Make sure that the cupcakes are COMPLETELY cooled before frosting. If the cupcake is warm, the butter in the frosting will melt right off the cupcake.

  53. I have been looking for a new cupcake recipe because my last few batches with my old tried and true have just come out ho-hum. Can’t wait to try this one. Just a question: can this recipe be used in a bundt pan? I am sure the time would have to be adjusted, but I am looking for a lighter cake. Most bundt cakes are denser, like pound cakes. Just a question. Thanks!

  54. My kids and I are going to make these today then write on my blog about it thanks so much for sharing this easy recipe!!

  55. Can i substitute the vanilla paste with vanilla essence or vanilla powder? If so what will be the measurement? Thanks!

    • I have substituted vanilla extract in the same measurement with success. I’ve never used essence or powder. You can also scrape a vanilla bean into the batter if you have one!

  56. Can I use vanilla extract instead of vanilla bean paste ? Would it make a difference ?

  57. Alisha Larson says:

    I was looking for a cupcake recipe (from scratch) to make for a baby shower. I researched a lot of recipes and decided on yours. I like your blog and your realism– I don’t have cake flour lying around either. I like that you used things anyone would have in their kitchen. They turned out amazing! Mine made about 18 cupcakes, 2/3 full. I baked them for 16 minutes and voila! Perfect delicious moist vanilla cupcakes. I couldn’t find vanilla paste so I splurged and purchased PURE vanilla extract. All my research states to get the best of the best ingredients and I guess I can spend a few more dollars and not buy the imitation extract. Eek! I used 1 T plus 1 tsp of vanilla extract. My eggs were room temperature as well. Thank you! I will make these again.

    • Yay! I’m so glad you liked them Alisha! Yes, if you can, always splurge for the pure vanilla extract. If you happen to belong to Costco (or know someone who does) they sell large bottles of it for the price of one jar of the expensive stuff. That’s what I use! Thanks for letting me know you like them!

  58. I made these cupcakes just for fun. I followed the directions and everything however they tasted a little odd. Maybe that is how they are spose to taste. But not my thing.
    If you are looking for regular cupcakes I would not advise making these, however if you want to try something new than forsure try these :)

  59. Just tried this recipe two.days ago and I must say it was the absolute best cupcake recipe ever!
    The bf could not stop with the compliments. This will now be our household regular. Thank you!

  60. These cupcakes were GREAT! I’ve been looking for a good “go-to” vanilla cupcake recipe for a long time and I think I found it! The cupcakes rose up nicely and were delicious and fluffy! They were super simple to make as well. I did use Mexican vanilla in mine which added a slightly different flavor but we loved it. Will be looking at more of your recipes for sure! Thanks!

  61. Eden Alexi says:

    I really want to try this recipe but my oven doesn’t have a temperature adjuster so what method should i use? And sorry for the grammar error English isn’t my mother tongue language.

  62. If I am in a pinch with only extract, how much should I use for the cake? Thank you!

  63. do you need to use vanilla paste

  64. LOVE this recipe! The only thing I changed was the whipped cream. I thought it didn’t go well, so instead I added a vanilla PASTRY cream! YUM!

  65. was looking for an improved vanilla cupcake recipe today and found this one
    doubled the recipe and used one split vanilla bean
    not sure where others went wrong, but i had absolutely fantastic results – so delicious! this will be my go-to recipe from now on.
    thanks so much!

  66. I have made these before and they are incredible. It helps that this is the FIRST result when you Google “Best Vanilla Cupcakes”. I have some in the oven now. It’s 11:00 at night and I NEED A CUPCAKE THIS IS NOT A DRILL!!

  67. Stephanie says:

    I’ve never posted a comment on a blog…normally just a stalker. But, these deserve a million comments and shares and KUDOS! Amazing! I made them last night and they are PERFECT. My new favorite go-to cupcake!

  68. Hi Dorothy, I made these and they were a hit..I have now had a request for a birthday cake using the same recipe…Would it work do you think?
    Nanette , Australia

  69. Hi how long does the frosting holds its shape at room temperature?thanks.i love the cupcake they are moist.

  70. Hi how long does the frosting holds its shape at room temperature? I love the cupcake they are moist!

  71. Okay, so it is half past 12 at night, and I am baking these cupcakes! And I must say, these are by far the best vanilla cupcakes I’ve ever made :) Thanks so much for the recipe, I’m going to make them for my mom’s 50th birthday next week :D

  72. shida 101 says:

    i dnt no what i did mines didnt came out rite and my mixter was realy watery where did i go wrong?

    • The batter is more liquidy than a box mix or a recipe that uses softened butter (the melted butter makes them thinner). But they should bake up just fine. Did they bake up ok?

      • shida 101 says:

        no they didnt they were like tough and tasted funny n they didnt raise for like a half hour

        • Is your baking powder fresh? That would cause the cupcakes to not rise. Check the expiration date on it. The only other thing could be the addition of too much milk? Other than that I’m sorry, I’m not sure what could have happened. I’ve made these successfully several times.


  1. […] I found this excellent recipe of Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes from Dorothy at Crazy for Crust that would make 12-15 cupcakes.  I didn’t have vanilla bean […]

  2. […] Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes: so simple, but so good. Everyone needs a perfect vanilla cupcake in their repertoire, and this is […]

  3. […] up the regular classic Oreos and put them in some very perfect vanilla cake batter. I adapted these Perfect Vanilla Cupcakes from Crazy for Crust to yield 6 mini cakes (you can also two thin 9″ rounds, bake time […]

  4. […] cake is based on my Perfect Vanilla Cupcake recipe (which later turned into my Perfect Funfetti Cupcake recipe). I substituted whole milk for […]

  5. […] Harvest Bread Company, who sells the flour they mill in their shop by the pound. I settled on vanilla cupcakes and they tasted phenomenal — although have you ever had a bad cupcake?! After that success, […]

  6. […] have a favorite vanilla cupcake or frosting recipe, please let me know! :) I think I’ll try these or these […]

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge

All content, including recipes, text, visual elements, and photographs are copyright (c) Crazy for Crust 2010-2013, unless otherwise stated. All rights reserved.