This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, read my disclosure policy.
When your chocolate peanut butter craving hits I have the perfect solution for you: this Chocolate Peanut Butter Dip. It only has 2 ingredients, which means you can eat it even faster.
Also? It’s Mel Approved. (<- That right there? Means the recipe is golden.)
I made this dip for the Super Bowl and I’m just now sharing it with you. Please don’t be mad at me?
I know I always say “this was soooo good!” about pretty much everything I make. But this dip? Holy cow. It was out on the table all afternoon and into the evening and I couldn’t stop eating it. Eventually I gave up on the dippers and just ate it with a spoon.
Mel couldn’t stand it – he even gave in and ate some. And if you have read this blog for any length of time, you’ll know that my husband eating something I make requires 3 gold stars on the calendar and it also means that pigs were probably flying and unicorns came to visit.
Yup, this chocolate peanut butter dip is that good. And? It’s only 2 ingredients. And? It’s easy to make less or more of it depending on if you’re serving a part of 1 or 15. I can kind of guess what you’re all having for dessert tonight. 🙂
This dip came about because, when I grocery shop, I am addicted to the little tag by the price that says NEW PRODUCT. I have always been that way. New product means I want to try it. Always.
One of my favorite grocery stores is Safeway. I have one right by my house and I shop there a few times a month. I love how I can load up coupons on my Club Card online, print my shopping list, and then just watch the savings add up at the register.
Safeway has tons of new items right now in every corner of their store. They consistently get all the new products that brands have to offer and, well, because I’m a sucker for NEW! I end up buying new stuff every time I go there.
So, thanks to Safeway and their love of new products (and their love of putting those products on sale), I made chocolate peanut butter dip using some of my new favorite things: HONEY MAID Go Bites and REESE’S® Spread.
HONEY MAID Go Bites are like graham cracker bites with a filling in the center (chocolate or vanilla). Jordan loves them and begs for them in her lunch every day.
REESE’S® Spread…how do I explain it? Unicorn dust? Magical fairy juice? Something I ate with a spoon? Pretty much it tastes like peanut butter cups that have been put in a blender. #sorrynotsorry
Since I happened to find these new products right before we were having company to watch football, I decided to make this into a dip. It’s easy to make, easy to serve, and even easier to eat.
And, like I said, there are only 2 ingredients: the spread and nonfat vanilla greek yogurt.
A few notes about the recipe:
My recipe calls for equal parts (1/2 cup each) of the spread and yogurt. That served about 8 people. It’s easy to make more or less depending on how many people you’re serving.
Use a yogurt that you love. Not all greek yogurts are the same. Some are thicker and more tangy than others. If you use a yogurt that you like it’s more likely that the dip will be to your liking. I like a thinner less tangy greek yogurt so I lean towards brands like Yoplait or the Safeway brand, Lucerne. Both aren’t too heavy. You can also use regular non-greek yogurt if you like. (I used nonfat because that’s what I buy. If you buy regular or low fat, you can use that as well.)
The HONEY MAID Go Bites were perfect for dipping. Pretzels, graham crackers, and fresh fruit would also be great for this dip.
And don’t forget about the spoon. That’s my favorite dipper. 🙂
Easy Chocolate Peanut Butter Dip
- 1/2 cup REESE'S® Chocolate Peanut Butter Spread
- 1/2 cup nonfat vanilla greek yogurt
- Chopped mini peanut butter cups optional for garnish
- Assorted dippers: cookies pretzels, fruit, and/or HONEY MAID Go Bites
- Stir together REESE'S® spread and yogurt. Be sure to use a yogurt you love. Different greek yogurts have different thicknesses and textures, so use one that is appealing to you. You can also use regular nonfat vanilla yogurt if you prefer.
- Serve with assorted dippers. Store in refrigerator, best served room temperature.
Click here to see more PEANUT BUTTER recipes!
Connect with Safeway and their partners:
Vons / CARRS / Tom Thumb / Randalls
This post was sponsored by Safeway. All opinions are 100% my own.
Last Updated on September 23, 2019
Excuse me for being so crass but I want to figure out how to drink this!
I have yet to try the Reese’s spreads, but this seems like a good place to start, and I am going to have to hunt down those Honey Maid bites (or find a way to make my own)
That Reese’s spread is seriously the most dangerous thing on the shelf right now! I can’t stop eating spoonfuls of it…seriously, I’m surprised I was even able to make one recipe from it. I love that this dip is just 2 ingredients…and all I see is protein when I look at it 😉
It so totally is!! Oh my gosh, I ate the rest of the jar, no joke.
I’m surprised it lasted all afternoon! My husband and I would have polished it off in one sitting! Can’t resist chocolate and peanut butter!
Stop it right now! You know how much I love dessert dips! This is going on the must-make list. Love that it’s only two ingredients – pinned & yummed!
Thanks for pinning Jen!! <3
Oh MY!!! This looks dangerously delicious! Love your nails! 😉
Thanks Kathleen! They’re Jamberry!
WHY must I live in a tiny town where we don’t get fun new products?!? I will be adding these to my list for when I head to the big ole city to shop. Pinned!!
You must! And thanks for the pin!
I am buying Honey Maid graham crackers again (yippee!); now, if they will just take the hydrogenated oil out of Ritz crackers (Nabisco, are you out there? Are you listening?). Then I could use those for this fabulous dip.
We would not survive without Ritz crackers here! LOL 🙂
That looks fantastic. I’ve never seen that Reese’s spread, but I made a similar dip once with cocoa, yogurt and peanut butter. I think we finished it in about 5 minutes flat. So good. Then I promptly forgot about it. Until just now, while reading this! Need to make yogurt dip again! Pinned!
Thank you for pinning!!
I wish we could get Reese’s spread here, it looks so good! I may actually have to put peanut butter cups in the blender! Haha
DO IT! That’s what the spread tastes like!!