Crazy for Crust

Jun 04

Crumb Apple Pie

Pin It

So this is a recipe re-do. I made it in the first few months of this blog. And, well, I’m not proud of how the post looks. When Ashton mentioned doing a re-do post and making it a blog hop, I knew immediately that I was going to re-make this pie.

You see, this pie is special. One, my husband loves it. He cannot turn it down (and ate two slices of it).

And two, it’s the pie that inspired the blog name. Because we love the crust and the crumb of this pie more than the apple filling and one night, chowing down, the idea for a crust-loving store/site/something was born.

And now, here I am, a few years later, working on that dream.

So this pie needed a new place here on this site. Badly.

Plus, it’s always good to re-do some things in life. What would you re-do, if you could?

I would definitely go back and pay more attention to the HTML unit in my programming class in college, instead of copying off my future husband.

I would re-do so many things about my wedding. The colors (um, evergreen? really?) and the attendants.

But not the cake. No way, I wouldn’t change that for the world.

I’d go back in time to the sixth grade and tell myself, do NOT crimp your hair for your school photo. Have you ever seen someones head look like a triangle?

Oh, and for sure I would go back to when I saw City of Angels (you know, Meg Ryan and Nicholas Cage) and leave 10 minutes before the ending. I stayed until then end of the movie, and it still haunts me.

I might have re-done the pictures of this pie, and the post. But I will never change the ingredients or the way I make it. Except maybe to add more crumble. More crumble is always better.

My secret in this pie? I cook the apples a little before adding them to the pie crust. I don’t like chewy apples. (Are you surprised?)

I also make my crust with butter only. No offense to shortening users. I’m just not a huge fan. So I use all butter.

Butter is good.

Tart apples. Sweet cinnamon. Crunchy, sweet, crumbly topping. Add some ice cream and you’ve got a meal.

Hmmm…I may have to re-do it again. I don’t know if I like the pictures enough… šŸ˜‰

Crumb Apple Pie


For the Crust:

  • 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 cup butter, diced and chilled
  • 3-4 tablespoons of ice water

For the Filling:

  • 6 or 7 large Granny Smith apples
  • Ā¼ - Ā½ cup sugar
  • Ā¾ teaspoons cinnamon

For the Crumb:

  • 2/3 cup sugar
  • 1 Ā½ cups flour
  • 12 tablespoons butter, slightly softened


  1. Make the Crust: Combine flour and salt in food processor. Add butter and process until it resembles coarse crumbs.
  2. Add water, one tablespoon at a time, until mixture forms a ball.
  3. Two options for the next step: wrap in plastic and refrigerate 4 hours or overnight, until ready to use OR roll out crust immediately between two pieces of wax paper and press into pie plate. Chill at least 30 minutes, while you are getting the rest of the filling ready.
  4. This recipe makes one crust. Double recipe to make a two-crust pie.
  5. Make the Filling and Assemble: Peel and slice apples to desired thickness. Place one inch of water in the bottom of a large pot. Add apples and cook, stirring occasionally, approximately 5 minutes. You want the apples semi-opaque but not mushy.
  6. While apples are cooking, add the crumb ingredients to a large bowl. Using a fork or pastry cutter, cut the ingredients together until they form coarse crumbs, about the size of a pea.
  7. Drain apples well and place in chilled pie shell. Sprinkle remaining Ā¼ - Ā½ cup sugar (depending on your desired sweetness) and cinnamon over apples. Add your crumb mixture evenly on top. Place pie on a cookie sheet to avoid mess in the oven.
  8. Bake at 400Ā° for 35-40 minutes. You may need to cover center of pie with foil during baking if your crumb topping is browning too fast.
  9. To make the star toppers, I used a refrigerated pie crust I had laying around. Cut your shapes and add to the top of the crumb before baking.
  10. Pie may be made a day in advance. Refrigerate overnight. Serve with whipped cream or ice cream.

70 comments on “Crumb Apple Pie

  1. Dorothy,

    It’s interesting that you would re-do your wedding attendants. A few years ago I was in a similar conversation and I think a lot of people would re-do the same. My how life changes.

    Good job on this Apple Pie re-do, looks delicious.

  2. These photos soo do not need a re-do,they are drool-worthy! All I want is that slice at the end with a big dollop of ice-cream :) Crimping hair? Ya I think everyone is guilty of that,ha ha triangle head..ahh the memories:)

  3. My husband is totally crazy for pie – adding this to my must make list! I love the addition of the little stars on top. So glad you decided you’re crazy for crust and started this blog :)

  4. Your pie looks awesome, and so do your pictures. If you think something needs a re-do, check out my first blog pictures–yikes! My hubby loves apple pie; I’m pinning this one to make for a special occasion!

  5. Oh girl this looks fantastic. Your stories crack me up. I could never get crimping to work, so instead I spiral permed my hair. Not cool my friend, not cool. This pie though? Very cool!

  6. Holy crap, this looks so good. Apple pie is my beyond fave pie EVER and the crumbier the better! Plus, I love the stars :) and I remember getting a crimper in elementary school because I wanted my hair to look like–*drumroll*–a Barbie doll’s hair. Note: crimping looks good on Barbie’s hair since well, she’s Barbie and that chick can do no wrong, but crimping does NOT look okay in real life. Ughhhhh.

  7. I love the idea of the stars on top of the crumb crust; it really would be perfect for the July 4th picnic. I also cook my apples first to release some of the juices and use some concentrated apple cider to flavor them.
    Apple Pie for breakfast would be fantastic this morning! XOXO

  8. Looks like you nailed it in your re-do! Yep, definitely can’t have TOO MUCH crumble:) I want to re-do MANY of my first post~yikes!

  9. I agree! Butter is always good! Can’t go wrong with a little “Julia Child’ right? (;

  10. ummmmm YES– I think you should definitely re-do this post. I mean, it’s clearly still not right. So let’s say another re-do around Christmas time? When I’m in Cali???? And you’ll re-do this pie again?? YESSSSS.

  11. Sigh. I just want a piece of this so badly. I’m sad now. I better go make one myself!

  12. This pie looks so good and is so pretty! xo

  13. I love that I’m not the only one who cooks the apples first. Crunchy apples in pie kinda creeps my mouth out.

  14. I truly believe that shortening makes everything better. But we can agree to disagree :)
    My cousin (in 2000) had John Deere green and yellow (with sunflowers) as her wedding colors. If I could go back, I’d probably blow more money on my wedding. Everyone says it was great, but I would’ve gone with a more upscale venue, better photographers, and a better DJ.

  15. What a beautiful and delicious looking pie!!!!

  16. This looks like the ultimate apple pie. I am feeling a little star struck by it’s inspiring famousness. You even put pie crust stars on top, LOVE! I am with you, butter all the way. What would I redo….let’s not go there.

  17. Hi Dorothy,

    I just wanted you to know that your contribution for My Sweet Party was amongst my top three favourites. Your Chocolate dipped peanut butter donuts looked and sounded amazing!!! Please check out the post were I featured you here

    Btw your apple pie is adorable!!



  18. Oh I love apple pie and this is pinned so I can totally make it!! And I totally agree about some of those redo in my life (my wedding colors were horrid, the perm is 9th grade was even worse, the red wranglers and cowboy boots in junior high were not very flattering, and the list goes on). Thank heavens we get to redo recipes on our blogs because wow all of us have come so far!! :)

    The Farm Girl

  19. I would re-do YOUR re-do anytime…looks so yummy. Hey, hilarious on the hair crimp comment, I know that all too well.

  20. I am now a HUGE fan of apple pie with crumb topping…And, yes, you would love it with cheese. šŸ˜‰

  21. I need a huge slice of this awesome pie while contemplate what all I would redo!!! Love the cute extra pie crust stars!!! I’m thanking my lucky stars that the crimper never worked on curly hair;-)

  22. Your pie looks amazing!!! Wonderful pics! You are so funny. I would re-do a ton of moments. The crimping hair one made me laugh! Mine would be the Dorothy Hammel haircut in 6th grade. Hello! It didn’t even look good on here! What was I thinking??!!

    On another note =o) I made your S;more Cookie Tarts and they were AMAZING!!! But I failed at following your directions so they aren’t as cool looking as yours. But the taste? Fantastic! Thanks!

  23. What a cute idea! I like the re-do party theme! Your apple crumb sounds wonderful. Your post is funny, too! Thanks for the stories.

  24. Hey there! Love your blog! I found you via the MMM blog hop and just added myself to your followers! Also I wanted to invite you to come enter a fabulous Steve Madden giveaway I’m having right now!!
    Hope to see you there! And thanks so much lady!

  25. Don’t have to convince me – I looooooooove crumb-apple-pie and lucky me all my family share my feeling
    I love the little stars on top – wonderful idea!

  26. This looks SO good! Thanks so much for linking up with “Try a New Recipe Tuesday!” We love apple pie here and definitely are going to try this one! :-)

  27. Your apple pie looks lovely! What a great idea for a hop. I totally have a blog post that I want to redo! It was one of my very first posts and its been getting a lot of hits lately and the pictures just aren’t very good!

  28. I am not fan of shortening as well. Butter works just fine! your recipe sounds reaaly great!

  29. The best part of that pie is the stars on top. Love it!


  30. Mmmm, I would definitely love a slice of that pie! And I like a good amount of crust-to-filling myself :)

  31. Found you on Mopping it up Monday’s…the pie looks awesome along with a lot of your other recipes.

    I’m your newest follower.

    Kimberly @

  32. Oh man am I crazy for crust also. I found this on pinterest and will have to make this the next time I make apple pie. So happy to be your newest follower. When you have a chance come by and check me out at

  33. Looks delicious! And I wold skip the end of City of Angels too!

  34. Looks so good. What a great blog you have makes me hungry lol. If you have a min check out mine if you have not already :)

    have a great day

  35. Wow! This looks very yummy, and it just might be on our weekend menu, now. Thank you for sharing.

    Here’s my post for the Linky:

  36. Pingback: Apple Butter Pie Bars | Crazy for Crust

  37. Pingback: Blueberry Slab Pie | Crazy for Crust

  38. Pingback: Pie Round-Up | Crazy for Crust

  39. Pingback: Peppermint Crumble Bars - Something Swanky

  40. Pingback: Blueberry Crumb Pie - Crazy for Crust

  41. Pingback: Funfetti Gooey Bars - Crazy for Crust

  42. Pingback: Apple Gorgonzola Crostata - Crazy for Crust

  43. Pingback: Apple Butter Pie Bars - Crazy for Crust

  44. Thank you so much for this recipe. I don’t like crunchy apples in my apple pie, so the cooking them a bit first does sound like the solution. I’m planning on making this for Thanksgiving using your all butter crust recipe. The crumb topping reminds me of what my mother uses on her cherry crumb pie, except she uses shortening instead of butter.

    • Crumble is the BEST! And cooked apples are the bees knees!

      • Dorothy, one last question: Can I use an assortment of apples instead of Granny Smith? I want to use what I have in my produce drawer in the fridge, if I can. I am so looking forward to this pie. Can you tell?

      • You can use whatever apples you like! I’ve never made them with anything but Granny Smith, and I know that other apples are less crisp, so you may need to precook them less. Enjoy!

      • The pie was excellent! I used the apple assortment and it turned out great–no crunchy apples, either. The crumb topping was so good. This recipe is a keeper. Thank you so much!

  45. Pingback: Mini Crumb Apple Pies - Crazy for Crust

  46. Such a cute looking pie!!! I love the stars you have added to it. Will surely try :)

  47. Pingback: Berry Crisp with Oatmeal Cookie Crumble - Crazy for Crust

  48. Pingback: Crockpot Apple Dump Cake - Crazy for Crust

  49. That pie has me drooling.

  50. Amazing! Easy to make and amazingly good to eat!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *