Is your brown sugar as hard as a rock? Learn how to soften brown sugar quickly using one of these methods and how to store it so it will stay soft!
Never throw away clumpy brown sugar again when you learn how to fix it!
Table of Contents
How to Soften Brown Sugar Video
Why does brown sugar get hard?
It’s the worst feeling when you go to use your brown sugar and it’s hard as a rock! Or – even worse – when you buy a box of sugar and by the time you even open it it’s hardened up.
Don’t worry – hardened brown sugar isn’t ruined. You can easily soften hard brown sugar. There are also ways to store it to keep it soft and I’m going to talk about all the methods here today.
First, you have to know what brown sugar is made of: white sugar and molasses. The molasses in the sugar hardens when exposed to air because the moisture in the molasses evaporates, causing the sugar to clump together. Once the molasses dries out the brown sugar hardens and turns into a solid block of sugar.
Don’t worry though, hard brown sugar is still good – you just have to soften it.
Soften brown sugar quickly in the microwave
The fast way to soften brown sugar is to heat it in the microwave. Here’s what to do:
- Place your desired amount of hardened brown sugar in a microwave safe bowl.
- Saturate a paper towel with water and ring it out. Place the damp towel over the brown sugar in the bowl.
- Heat it on high power in 30 second increments, until it’s softened.
Be sure to watch it so it doesn’t get too hot – brown sugar will turn to liquid if heated too long.
After a minute or two, depending on the amount of sugar, it will be soft enough to pack it and use it in your recipe.
How to Soften Brown Sugar with Bread
If you’re not in a rush and realize your brown sugar is clumped then you can easily soften it over time.
Simply add a slice of bread or a slice of apple to the canister of brown sugar and allow it to sit. After a few days, the brown sugar will be soft again!
I prefer using the slice of bread method to the apple (there’s something gross about adding a wet apple to my canister of brown sugar).
This is a foolproof way of softening brown sugar!
Other Ways to Soften Brown Sugar
- Use apple slices in place of bread
- Use the oven instead of microwave: heat the oven to 200° and wrap your brown sugar in parchment paper or foil. Bake about 5-10 minutes, checking after 3 minutes to see how it’s going.
- Use a dampened paper towel: Place the brown sugar in a bowl. Wet a paper towel and wring it out. Place it over the brown sugar and let it sit for several hours.
How do you store brown sugar so it doesn’t get hard?
The trick is to store your brown sugar properly in the first place so it doesn’t have a chance to get hard.
- Use Airtight Food Storage Containers to store your baking ingredients. Reducing the chance of air in the container will reduce the hardening of your brown sugar.
- Use a Brown Sugar Saver, which is a piece of terra-cotta that, when soaked in water then added to your brown sugar canister, will maintain moisture for 3-6 months. (TIP: it also will preserver marshmallows, dried fruit and you can use it when you mail cookies or cakes to keep them soft!) **This can also be used in place of a slice of bread to soften your sugar if it’s already hardened.
Never fear – your brown sugar is not ruined if it gets hard. Simply use one of these methods to soften it and use it as normal!
All text and images © DOROTHY KERN for Crazy for Crust. Please do not use my images without prior permission. If you want to republish this recipe, please re-write the recipe in your own words, or link back to this post for the recipe. Disclaimer: Nutrition information shown is not guaranteed to be accurate.
This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, read my disclosure policy.
Published on: June 8, 2021