Crazy for Crust

Feb 27

Thin Mint S’mores

You guys. This recipe for Thin Mint S’mores is so easy it’s almost not even a recipe. There’s only two ingredients!

Thin Mint S'mores | | The easiest recipe ever!

Does something ever just hit you and you think “Duh, why haven’t I thought of that before??!!”

That happens to me a lot. More than I’d like to admit, actually.

I mean, it pretty much happens every time I open up Bloglovin to read food blogs. Am I right?

Anyway, the other day at the gym, Hayley and I were torturing ourselves on the stair master and talking about dessert.

{What else is there to talk about on the stair master? Oh, and did you know that Hayley and I are neighbors? She’s, like, the coolest person ever to work out with. Can you say donut leggings?}

We got on the topic of Girl Scout Cookies and what we wanted to do with them and s’mores popped into my head.

I almost considered not even posting it. I mean, it’s so…simple. But then I tasted them.

You all NEED to know about this idea.

Thin Mint S’mores.

Thin Mint S'mores | | The easiest recipe ever!

Two Thin Mints (or the Keebler Grasshoppers) sandwich a roasted marshmallow.

No need for chocolate bars. No need for graham crackers. Just Thin Mints and marshmallows.

{Side note: think of the possibilities! Oreos. Tagalongs. SAMOAS.}

To toast your marshmallow you have three options:

1. The most fun: blowtorch. Just be careful of your curtains and eyebrows.

2. Over a gas stove. They catch fire easily this way, but it’s (sort of) like an open fire.

3. An actual open fire. But that would mean camping and,well, I don’t camp. Actually, I don’t do fire either, which is why I should get a medal for doing #1 AND #2 for this post.

This is the perfect dessert to take with you on your summer camping trip. Freeze some Thin Mints and pack them when you go.

Or, you know, go make them now. Because it’s too easy not to!

Thin Mint S'mores | | The easiest recipe ever!

Seriously, I’m doing this with Samoas next. And Tagalongs. And maybe even Lemonades!

{Psst….if you love Girl Scout recipes – the ones harming the cookies and the ones emulating them – check out my BFF Ashton’s blog, Something Swanky. She’s doing 3 weeks of girl scout cookies! Find all the recipes here.}

Thin Mint S’mores

Yield: 1 smore per two cookies

Thin Mint S’mores


  • Thin Mint Cookies (2 per s’more) or you can use the Keebler Grasshopper Cookies (or any cookie!)
  • Large Marshmallows (1 marshmallow makes 2 s’mores)


  1. Cut each marshmallow in half with kitchen scissors.
  2. Roast marshmallow over a gas stove, an open fire, or with a kitchen blowtorch.
  3. Sandwich roasted marshmallows between 2 Thin Mint cookies. Serve warm.

Deep Dish Thin Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies


Samoa Magic Bars

Samoa Magic Bars (4 of 7)w

Brownie Cookie S’mores

brownie-cookie-smores (4 of 5)w

Sweets from friends:
Homemade Thin Mints by Averie Cooks
Cream Cheese Thin Mints by Kitchen Meets Girl
Better Than Thin Mints Grasshopper Poke Cake by Something Swanky


 Subscribe via email and have sugar delivered straight to your inbox!

80 comments on “Thin Mint S’mores

  1. This is a bit late…I thought of the idea and wondered if others had tried and how it worked out. Glad to see it does work well.

    I thought I would add that toaster ovens work well. Mine takes about 3 minutes but the marshmallows get browned and puffy, and you can turn them over after 2.5 minutes if you like both sides carmelized.

  2. Pingback: Weekend Wrap Up 3.1 | ebb + flow

  3. Pingback: Girl Scout Cookie Dessert Round Up! 30+ Recipes!

  4. Pingback: Thin Mint Marshmallow Brownies - The Food Charlatan

  5. Pingback: 25 Must-Make Girl Scout Cookie Recipes - Is This Really My Life | Is This Really My Life

  6. Pingback: Thin Mint S’mores | Old Capitol Inn

  7. Pingback: The Thursday Thirteen – 06/25/2015

  8. Pingback: Here's To the Weekend! - Bloguettes

  9. Pingback: 28 Ways To Step Up Your S’mores |

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *