Crazy for Crust

Feb 18

Nutter Butter Butterscotch Blondies

A blondie bar taken to a whole new level with chopped Nutter Butter Cookies, Peanut Butter Chips, and Butterscotch!

nutter butter butterscotch blondies

Oh hi there! You recognize me right? It’s me, Crazy for Crust. I went to the beauty salon this past weekend and got some work done. Maybe you noticed my new ‘do?

{Or maybe you’re reading in a reader? Or in an email? And have no idea what I’m talking about? Click on through, come on. You don’t want to miss it!}

That’s right! My baby Crazy for Crust got herself a new look! Isn’t it fabulous????

As much as I loved what I designed when I switched over to WordPress, there was just so much I wanted that I could not figure out. Little nagging things that bugged me every. single. day. And now it’s all fixed! And purty!

I’d like to give a huge shout-out thank you to Vanessa at Nifty Thrifty Things. She’s amazing! Not only do I have a normal-width sidebar now, but I also have super cool recipe pages! They’re, like, visual and stuff. So go browse around! Find some sugar.

But wait. Don’t go just yet. You want to pin these blondies first. For later. Because, well. If there is only one thing I love more than my new blog design, it might be these blondies.


nutter butter butterscotch blondies

Blondies may not be a new idea…but they sort of are to me. I only recently found my go-to blondie recipe, and I’ve had so much fun lately recreating new versions. As much as I love chocolate, there’s something about a rich, brown sugary blondie that just satisfies, you know?

These blondies are brought to a new level with the addition of some of my favorite things: Nutter Butter Cookies, peanut butter chips, and butterscotch. I mean, that’s like the trifecta of awesomeness for a bar, am I right?

If you’ve never had Nutter Butters, they are a peanut butter sandwich cookie. I will put aside that fact that I don’t understand how you’ve lived life as an American without tasting one. (I’ll excuse my International friends because I know the wonder that is the Nutter Butter doesn’t often exist outside the USA.) Whatever your excuse, get yourself to the store and get a pack, okay? Then make pie and brownies out of them. Oh, and make these. Make these first!

I added the cookies and peanut butter chips in the batter. Combined with the brown sugar, this creates a soft, chewy, nutty bar. Then, while the bars were still hot and  not-quite-done, I sprinkled the top with butterscotch chips. Put the pan back in the oven for a few minutes so the chips can melt. As soon as you remove the pan from the oven, you can spread the chips evenly over the blondies. Butterscotch pairs well with…well anything. But really, it pairs amazingly with peanut butter. Trust me!

nutter butter butterscotch blondies

 Now excuse me while I go oogle my site a little…. 😉

Nutter Butter Butterscotch Blondies

Nutter Butter Butterscotch Blondies


  • 2 cups brown sugar
  • 1/2 cup (1 stick) butter
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 2 cups flour
  • 1/2 cup butterscotch chips
  • 1 bag (about 2 cups) peanut butter chips, divided
  • 14 Nutter Butter cookies, coarsely chopped
  • Sprinkles, any color


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Line a 9x13” pan with foil and spray with cooking spray.
  2. Cream brown sugar and butter in the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with a paddle attachment. Add eggs and vanilla and beat until combined. Add baking powder, salt, and flour and mix. Mix in butterscotch chips,1/2 cup peanut butter chips, and Nutter Butters. 
  3. Press into prepared pan (dough is sticky, spray your hands with cooking spray to avoid it sticking to your hands). Bake at 350 for 23 minutes. Remove from oven and sprinkle remaining peanut butter chips over the top of the hot bars. Return to oven for 2 minutes. Remove from oven and carefully spread the melting chips over the top of the bars to create a frosting. Sprinkle with sprinkles and let cool. (Be careful not to overcook - the center will still be jiggly when you take these out of the oven and they will finish cooking and firming up as they cool.) Cool completely before slicing into squares.

Check out these blondies too!

Very Vanilla Bars

50 shades vanilla 3 words

Peanut Butter Brownies with Pretzel Crust

peanut butter brownies 2 words


Sweets from friends:
Lemon Vanilla Dream Bars by Kitchen Meets Girl
White Chocolate and Caramel Blondies by Lil’ Luna
Caramel Cadbury Eggs Cookie Bars by Something Swanky

This post may be linked to: Chef in TrainingLil’ LunaBuns In My OvenChic-and-CraftyI’m Lovin’ it FridaysStrut your Stuff SaturdayWeekend Wrap Up PartySundae Scoop Link Partyand all of these too!

81 comments on “Nutter Butter Butterscotch Blondies

  1. Looks good around here Dorothy!!! And these blondies…oh my gosh. They have butterscotch. And we all know I LOVE me some butterscotch :)

  2. I love the new look! And I love the new blondies – you can never go wrong with peanut butter and butterscotch.

  3. wow – you have been a busy little designer/baker/blogger – makes me feel like a lazy bum:) I was just looking for ways to use butterscotch today

  4. LOVE the new blog design and , ok. These look like something that I need RIGHT NOW (as I am re-working my recipe gallery – ugh). Just YUMMMMM!
    Hugs, Claire

  5. Dorothy, the blog looks fantastic! And these Blondies look pretty darn amazing, too – wish I could reach through the screen and have one right now! Congrats on the great new design to showcase your wonderful work! ~Cindy

  6. Love these flavors! I have a Nutter Butter nobake bar recipe from like 2010 that I need to dust off. And I love blondies! PERFECT combo.

    Congrats on the new site. I was looking for someone to do the visual recipe indexing for AGES. Finally, my turn has come up on a designer’s wait list and am so excited but yeah, the past year have been emailing designers and no one was able to help. Remember when we emailed about thesis vs. genesis. A downfall of Thesis that no one seemed to be able to help with. Another reason be glad you went with Genesis!

  7. Everything looks great, especially the blondies.
    Love you,

  8. The problem I have with Nutter Butters is that they would probably never make it into these blondies. Pinning this (with true intention of trying them!)

  9. Those brownies look amazing…I’m pinning and will definitely be back to make them! And your new design is **awesome**!!! Congrats!

  10. Oh man! I wish I had some of these nutter butter blondies while watching The Bachelor tonight. Would of made wasting 2 hours more pleasing. :) I hope you had a great weekend with your family!!

  11. I noticed the new look when I popped over yesterday. It looks GREAT! Nothing wrong with a little touch up now and then.

  12. Dorothy, these look great! I forgot about my love for Nutter Butter cookies :) Yum!

  13. Love the new look! And these blondies… I can’t resist anything with Nutter Butters in them… then you had to go and throw in peanut butter and butterscotch chips!!! Looks soooo good!

  14. Site looks great!

    These Blondies look delightful. I am going to Florida next week… I think I will be looking for some nutter butters and cookie spread of course.

  15. The site looks pretty and these blondies look dangerous! I love the crunchy inside the chewy. Now I just need some Nutter Butters.

  16. Holy Cow Dorothy…these sound amazing! I love blondies and can’t wait to give them a try.

  17. Blondies, how I love you so! Seriously my favorite dessert — period. You can’t beat their greatness! I am LOOOOVING the fact that you added Nutter Butters AND butterscotch. Amazeballs, much? And I am also looooving your ritzy new blog design! I hope you know I’m gonna hound you for tips and help when I finally take mine in to get plastic surgery 😉

  18. Your blog looks amazing!!! And your blondies do, too!!!!

  19. I think the site looks great, and yep never tried a nutter butter, but it would literally kill hubby, so we will have to do without.

  20. This is just so wonderful I want it right now for my post breakfast dessert haha

  21. Oh these are like the perfect marriage of flavors! Can’t wait to try them :)

  22. The blog looks awesome! And yes you certainly did take the humble blondie to a whole new level with these bars! Yum!

  23. I love nutter butters! I also love blondies, and putting them together sounds amazing! Seriously, it’s kinda mean to post this much deliciousness when I’m trying to be good. lol. :)

  24. Looks pretty amazing! I’m talking about the blog and the bars!!! Butterscotch is my weakness! And I never met a blondie I didn’t like!! Nice job Dorothy!

  25. I LOVE the new look!! So colorful and happy! And now I want to make seven hundred different things from Nutter Butters.

  26. These blondies look so decadent and gooey and perfect. You can’t go wrong with a butterscotch/peanut butter combo. Love ’em, Dorothy!

  27. nutter butters + butterscotch? Not fair, just not fair. These sound so amazing! Nutter butters happen to be my dads 2nd favorite storebought cookie (if packaged oatmeal cream pies count as cookies… he thinks they do!)– he’s a busy accountant man, so I think he deserves my making him a fancy nutter butter blondie!

  28. The new site looks great.
    Love these bars though, blondies are kind of an obsession of mine!

  29. Pingback:

  30. Brownies will always be my fave BUT add nutter butters to blondies and you have my attention! :) They look perfect! And your site looks beautiful! Love love LOVE it(and you)!

  31. Well, you know how I feel about your new design!! But, I’ll say it again anyway: Vanessa is a freaking genius and I’m in love with every blog she touches 😉 (including yours, obviously)

    And these bars look AMAZING! I’ll be pinning soon!!

  32. Loooove the new look, Dorothy! Almost as much as these blondies (which totally look amazing!)

  33. Dorothy, you had me at Nutter Butters! Such a perfectly, clever combination of flavors.

  34. The new design is so spiffy … love it! I am pinning this recipe … butterscotch and Nutter Butters … it can’t get any better :)

  35. Love the new Look! I had forgotten that you were the blog that did the 50 shades party! I think of that post all the time and it makes me giggle! That is when I actually decided to read the series. These Nutter butter butterscotch blondies Oh My!

  36. Looks beautiful, Dorothy! And by that, I mean the site and the blondies! Truly delicious-looking…

  37. Blondies are seriously one of my favorite things. I make them all the time and make all different kinds. I love the idea of putting Nutter Butters in them, as well as using pb chips to make a frosting. Genius!

  38. These sound scrumptious!!!!

  39. Pingback: Whatever Friday {Instagram, Birthdays, and NKOTB} - Crazy for Crust | Crazy for Crust

  40. Yum, yum, yum! Pinned! Thanks for sharing at Two Cup Tuesday at Pint Sized Baker! Hope to see you there again on Monday night!

  41. Pingback: Loaded Oatmeal Blondies - Crazy for Crust

  42. Pingback: Peanut Butter Butterfinger Blondies - Crazy for Crust

  43. Pingback: The Best Blondie Recipe - Taste and Tell

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *