Pie Cookies

Pie Cookies by crazyforcrust.com

I can’t believe it. This is my 100th post.

And, as an added (unplanned but lucky) bonus, I hit 100 followers yesterday on Google Friend Connect.

Amazing, really. I’m speechless.

If you’d asked me a year ago, when this blog was still in my head and not out in the world, would I think I’d make 100 posts, I would have laughed. I probably would have said “Yeah right, what would I have to say for 100 posts?”

I guess I proved myself wrong.

I want to thank you, my readers, for reading my posts. My words. This blog has given me a new passion for something I’ve loved to do all my life. Now, when I watch Cupcake Wars, I take notes instead of just spectate. Making it to 100 posts is a milestone for me – because this means I know I can make it to 200 and beyond. I’m not doubting myself anymore.

How about some pie? I mean cookies? No, wait, pie???

There’s blueberry or cherry lattice pie.

Or how about pumpkin pie or banana cream?

A friend of mine introduced me to this method of decorating. She had made “pie” cupcakes at MOPS meeting and showed them to me after. I thought they were the cutest things ever and filed the method away to do at a later time. When I started thinking about this post, I figured, why not use cookies?

I used my favorite sugar cookie and icing recipes (see below). The filling is made from M&Ms.

The pie crust was piped using a #102 tip and the whipped cream was a #18 tip. These were so much fun to make. Even my daughter got in on the fun (and ended up covering her whole pie with “whipped cream” and then the rest of the M&Ms so it was a “do you want some cookie with that icing” pie).

“Pie” Cookies (and more!)

“Pie” Cookies (and more!)


  • Sugar cookies, cut into rounds (use your favorite cookie dough, or a refrigerated kind)
  • Vanilla frosting (your favorite recipe or a can)
  • M&Ms
  • Food Coloring


  1. Separate frosting into two bowls. Tint one bowl with brown food coloring and the other with white (for pure white "whipped cream"). Add to decorating bags. Spread a little frosting on each cookie and top with colored M&Ms for desired "filling." Pipe pie crust edge and lattice with brown frosting or whipped cream with white. Chill to harden.
Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin



 Subscribe via email and have sugar delivered straight to your inbox!

This post may be linked to all of these parties.


  1. Like you on facebook!

  2. Follow you on Twitter!

  3. Follow you on GFC and my favorite dessert is chocolate chip cookies :)Also– I’m having a giveaway this week too!! Make sure you’re at the party this week…

    {Sweet Treats Party}

  4. …and just tweeted your giveaway :)

  5. I love these! They are so cute! I’ll have to make these for my kids – they’ll love them.

  6. My fav dessert is ice cream. And I LOVE Sur La Table, too!

  7. Those look totally cute.

  8. I follow you on Facebook.

  9. I’m following you on Twitter.

  10. Hi! I follow you on facebook and twitter, and shared your giveaway with all my contacts. My favorite dessert is chocolate mousse. Congrats on your 100th post!

  11. What a cute idea!

  12. Chris R. says:

    I follow you on Facebook and I love Key Lime Pie!

  13. I’m a follower of your blog and my favorite dessert is probably ice cream. Although I do have a sweet tooth for just about anything!

  14. I just “liked” you on Facebook.

  15. I also follow you on Twitter. Thanks for the giveaway and congrats on 100 posts and 100 followers!

  16. Man, I wish I had a steady hand when it came to a piping bag. These are adorable!

  17. These are adorable. I saw your post on Mingle Monday. My favorite dessert is bread pudding! I am a follower!

  18. I am following you on twitter!

  19. Congrats on 100! Quite an accomplishment!! I like you on facebook!

  20. I tweeted your giveaway!

  21. a FAVORITE dessert? I don’t know if I can choose… whatever it is, it is served with ice cream. Like chocolate cake. Or brownies. Or cheesecake! DON’T MAKE ME CHOOSE!

  22. I follow you on facebook.

  23. And on twitter =)

  24. Congratulations on your 100 posts and 100 followers. :-)

    These cookies are super cute!

    I am a happy regular follower. :-) I love ice cream most of all, even in winter.

  25. I follow you on Twitter. :-)

  26. How exciting to read the big 1-0-0! Your pie cookies are just too adorable to eat. I’m a follower of yours already.

  27. Such an awesome giveaway! I’d love to win…my favorite dessert is cheesecake or cookies.

  28. Love your apple crumble recipe with a scoop of vanilla ice cream!

  29. Of course I like you and follow you on facebook! I don’t twitter but if I did I would totally follow you!

  30. These cookies are too cute!

  31. “liked” you on facebook!! I don’t do Twitter sorry:)

  32. I like you on facebook.

  33. I don’t have a favorite dessert because it depends on my mood so I will break it down. Favorite Cookie: hot chocolate, Favorite Cake: Italian Love Cake. Favorite Ice Cream: Chocolate with chopped fresh strawberries and bananas. Favorite Pie: Apple served hot with homemade vanilla ice cream. Thanks!

  34. This is really only 100?! You’re an insitution; I thought you’d been around forever! My favorite dessert would have to be a hot fudge brownie sundae. Or a Napoleon. Or a cupcake. Or all 3!!!

  35. Well heck I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE these cute cookie pies! So glad you linked them up to “Made it on Monday”.

    Of course I am a follower!
    And of course I “Like” you on FB!
    And my favorite dessert is CHEESECAKE! :)

  36. Trinette chow says:

    My favorite dessert is mud pie!


  37. Grinders chow says:

    Liked you on Fb!


  38. Anonymous says:

    I love Apple pie a la mode.

  39. Liked you on facebook!!

  40. I follow with Networked Blogs, and my favorite dessert is tiramisu!

    eemoody77 at gmail dot com

  41. I like you on Facebook!

  42. I follow you on Twitter! @FakeGradSchool

    eemoody77 at gmail dot com

  43. I tweeted!


    eemoody77 at gmail dot com

  44. Who was the lucky winner?

  45. Anonymous says:

    i shared your post on my wall. great ideas. can’t wait to try the pie cookies for my next family event! hulme3@comcast.net sue Hulme

  46. Anonymous says:

    great job!

  47. Soo stinkin’ cute! I have a cookbook that has those pie cupcakes in them and meant to make them as a cute treat for april fools day this year.. mmm… yeah didn’t happen. Maybe next year :)

    Congrats on 100 posts! Hope I will get that far someday

  48. THANK YOU so much for sharing your recipe with me at Cast Party Wednesday. I’d like to invite you back this week.
    I hope to see you again!

  49. Pssstt… Guess who made the TOP 3 Picks of
    “Made it on Monday”….


  50. @Katie @ Dip It In Chocolate
    You will before you know it!

    Thanks for reading! :)

  51. These are adorable. And they look easy — even better! Can’t wait to make them with my daughter. :) Now following Crazy for Crust on Facebook & Twitter (The Happy Acorn on both).

  52. @Lisa Ski
    Thanks! They are easy for sure. I hope your daughter likes them!


  1. […] Creative Pie Cookie via Crazy for Crust […]

  2. […] Pie Cookies from Crazy for Crust […]

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge

All content, including recipes, text, visual elements, and photographs are copyright (c) Crazy for Crust 2010-2013, unless otherwise stated. All rights reserved. DMCA.com