This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, read my disclosure policy.

My Pumpkin Peanut Butter Smoothie is a recipe we love having for breakfast. With just four ingredients it’s super easy to make. I know that pumpkin with peanut butter sounds weird but it’s really such a good combination! It’s actually one of my favorite fall flavor combos.

This post has been sponsored by the National Peanut Board. Peanut Butter is a staple ingredient in my house and we add it to smoothies constantly! I received compensation for this post, but all opinions are my own.

Pin it now to save for later

Pin Recipe

peanut butter smoothie in glass with whipped cream

I am always on the lookout for fast breakfast ideas because my daughter barely has time to get dressed in the morning before she has to leave for school. Smoothies are one of our favorite quick things she can take with her, so we make them often.

A peanut butter smoothie is a classic one, don’t you think? Every smoothie I make has some amount of peanut butter in it. Peanut butter is a staple in our house – we go through at least a jar a week, if not more – so it’s just a no-brainer that I toss some in our smoothies.

This isn’t just a plain old peanut butter smoothie recipe, however. This one gives your Thanksgiving leftovers a makeover by adding pumpkin pie filling to the mixture.

If you’re looking to make a peanut butter smoothie without banana, you can substitute pumpkin. Works like a charm!

You can substitute pumpkin pie mixture for banana in a peanut butter smoothie!
PRO TIP

What are the best things to put in a smoothie?

There are a few things that I put in every smoothie I make:

Peanut Butter – I prefer to use creamy for smoothies
Milk or nondairy milk, for blending
Protein powder for sweetness and extra protein
Fruit, like bananas or strawberries or pumpkin

Peanut Butter is an easy affordable ingredient for any smoothie. It packs a nice nutritious punch too: with each serving you get eight grams of protein and two grams of fiber!

I also love to add protein powder. You can make a chocolate peanut butter smoothie with chocolate flavor powder or do as I did and use vanilla. It adds a little sweetness as well as even more protein, making this a great breakfast.

(Protein powder is optional and can be omitted, if you prefer.)

If you’re looking to make a peanut butter smoothie without banana, then this is the perfect recipe for you!

Use leftover pumpkin pie to make a smoothie!

I’m no stranger to mixing pumpkin and peanut butter: remember that pumpkin quick bread? The flavor is the best so I knew I wanted to add pumpkin to a peanut butter smoothie.

You can use pumpkin puree OR pumpkin pie filling for this smoothie. Just be sure to follow the directions in the recipe for whichever one you use. Pumpkin pie filling is something we’ll all have leftovers of, so why not make a smoothie?

Anytime I can say I had pumpkin pie for breakfast…well that’s a good day!

Can we mix peanut butter with milk?

For sure – I always use some sort of milk, either regular or nondairy, in my smoothie recipes.

I made a note in the recipe, but be sure to add milk to your liking: if you want a thinner smoothie you can add more milk. For a thicker one, add less.

What can I put in a smoothie to thicken it?

There are several ways to thicken a smoothie:

Add more peanut butter! Peanut Butter is a natural thickener for smoothies.
Protein powder will also thicken your smoothie, if you add it.
Use less liquid or milk for a thicker smoothie.

However you make this easy smoothie recipe, your family is going to love it. I mean, your kids will love that they get to have pie for breakfast…but it’s much better than just eating a slice of pie!

Now it’s your turn! Spread the peanut butter love – share your favorite peanut butter recipe in the comments with #HowDoYouPB!

Visit this site for even more delicious peanut butter recipes for every occasion!

Other peanut butter recipes you’ll love:

Have you made this recipe?

Tag @crazyforcrust on Instagram or hashtag it #crazyforcrust