Silpat vs Parchment Paper for baking

Today I’m talking about why you should bake on parchment paper or use silicone baking mats: why, when, how and the differences between them.

If you look at every single one of my cookie recipes you’ll see that I call for lining them with parchment paper or silicone baking mats. This is because using a liner on your cookie sheet helps ensure baking success, not to mention helping with cleanup!

Pin it now to save for later

Pin Recipe
overhead photo of silpat on teal cookie sheet with roll of parchment paper on top

What is Parchment Paper?

Parchment paper is a specially treated paper processed to make it oven-safe and nonstick. The treatment also provides grease resistance and water resistance.

Parchment paper in baking, is used primarily as a nonstick surface in lieu of greasing a pan.

Pros for using Parchment Paper for baking:

  • Eliminates the need to grease your pan
  • Bakes more evenly than baking directly on a cookie sheet
  • Cuts easily to fit any size pan
  • Easily lift full slabs of brownies or bars out of the pan for clean cuts
  • It’s heat safe and repels grease and water
  • Great for lining pans when making no bake candies like chocolate truffles or bark
  • Easy clean up (just throw it away)

Cons for baking with parchment:

  • The length of a roll doesn’t fit quite right on a cookie sheet, so you usually have gaps at the top and bottom
  • While most parchment is reusable up to 3 times, it’s disposable, therefore not as environmentally friendly.
  • While it’s cheaper than buying silicone, you still have to purchase new rolls when you run out.

Where can you buy parchment paper?

There are tons of brands that sell it, but the most popular one is Reynolds. Every store has their own store brand as well. Find parchment paper at any grocery store, craft store, Target, Walmart, and Amazon.

Is parchment paper the same thing as wax paper?

NO NO NO it is not! Wax paper is coated in wax. Do NOT put wax paper in the oven. The wax will melt and burn. Wax paper is best for things like storing cookies or when you’re making a (no bake) candy or chocolate truffle.

cookies on parchment paper on cookie sheet

What is a Silpat Baking Mat?

Silpat is the most recognizable brand of silicone baking mat. A silicone baking mat is made of food-grade silicone and is used much in the same way as parchment: to line your pans in lieu of greasing. It’s nonstick and heat-safe and is another great way to ensure even baking.

Pros for baking on silicone:

  • Eliminates the need to grease your pan
  • Bakes more evenly than baking directly on cookie sheet
  • Heat safe, repels oil and water
  • Easy pan clean up (the silpat gets dirty but your pan stays clean)
  • Can also be used as a nonstick surface when making chocolate candy or bark
  • Doubles as a rolling mat for pie crust and doughs (the silicone acts like rubber – it won’t slip or slide).
  • Eco-friendly because it’s reusable

Cons for baking on silicone:

  • You have to wash them in hot soapy water to get any grease off (they’re not disposable)
  • Expensive investment up front
  • Comes in one size so you can’t cut it to fit your pan. If you’re using large cookie sheets or half sheets for baking, they fit but otherwise they’re too big.

Where do you buy Silpat or silicone baking mats?

If you want the original Silpat brand, you’ll need to shop at Williams-Sonoma, Sur La Table or Amazon.

If you just want silicone baking mats and don’t care which brand, you can find other less known brands at Target, Walmart and craft stores, or Amazon (I found Oxo Silicone Baking Mats on Amazon, but there are lots of brands too.)

cookies on cookie sheet with silpat baking mat

Why should you use parchment or silicone for baking?

So, now that you know what they are, why should use one of them?

In short, your recipes will turn out better if you bake on parchment paper or silicone.

  • Cookies will brown more evenly on the bottom
  • Cookies will spread considerably less than baked straight on a cookie sheet
  • The baking is more evenly distributed, allowing for a puffier cookie
  • No need to grease your pans = less greasy cookies

Regardless of which one you use, you should at least use one of them!

Which is better: Parchment Paper or Silpat?

It’s really personal preference! They both serve basically the same purpose but there are a few times when one is better than the other:

  • When baking something sticky (or making sticky candy), use silicone for easy removal.
  • Silicone is also best for things like macrons or delicate pastries
  • Brown Bottoms: silicone produces a lighter brown bottom than parchment, so go with your preference there
  • While many resources say cookies spread more on silicone, I find the opposite to be true: cookies spread more on parchment paper than Silpat baking mats. This is also even more apparent when you’re using a thick insulated baking sheet vs a cheaper thin one. The difference is very slight, but while writing my cookbook and baking hundreds of cookies on both, the cookies definitely spread more on the parchment paper. (However, I have not tested this theory on other brands of silicone baking mats.)

Final verdict: Dorothy’s recommendation

I recommend using both Silpat Baking Mats and parchment paper. Usually, when you’re baking cookies, you need to use more than one cookie sheet. I’ll often use one parchment and one silicone for easy cleanup. Parchment is also fantastic for lining your cake or brownie pans or even for cooking, so it’s definitely something that should be in your kitchen regardless.

overhead photo of silpat on teal cookie sheet with roll of parchment paper on top
Join for FREE to start saving your favorite recipes
Create an account easily save your favorite content, so you never forget a recipe again.
sample postsample postsample post

This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, read my disclosure policy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

3 CommentsLeave a comment or review

  1. I LOVE my Silpats. I’ve used them for several years now. Would highly recommend! Great article. Thank you Dorothy!

  2. What’s wrong with foil??? I have some parchment on top of foil and it fits nicely into a pan. Parchment is on a roll and it doesn’t lay flat. I hate it. I have some
    silpat and it is a pain to clean. I have 2 cookie sheets and cookies (any kind) never are a problem to remove from the sheet. I run them under water, give them a wipe and they are clean. I NEVER grease them. I’ve had them for 10 years and they are still shiny bright with no baked residue on them. They have a grain to the finish so they aren’t smooth. I buy the huge box of wide foil at Costco and it lasts me for years and I line my pans with it.