Crazy for Crust

2
Feb 26

Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookies

Do you ever feel like you have a double identity? I do.

There’s the way I am in the outside world and the way (I think I’m) perceived by others. And then there’s the way I am inside, where the little voices talk.

Often, I wonder if the people who see me on the outside know how I am on the inside.

Recently I hosted a mom’s night in at my house. Vodka was served. The inside Dorothy made quite an appearance, from what I recall. I think some of my friends were a little shocked.

But the funny thing? Is that’s the way I am all the time. Inside my head.

I just don’t have the nerve to say it all out loud. To people. Lest they judge me and not like me for making teenage boy jokes when someone says something about a long stick. (I told you. My sense of humor is all my mom’s fault. Blame her.)

I do, however, have the ability to do it in writing. Good thing I’m a blogger.

Hence the whole double identity thing. These cookies also have a double identity. Peanut butter on one side, chocolate on the other. It can’t decide what it wants to be, either.

These cookies could also be called “secret identity cookies.” Because they have a secret.

They’re made of cake mix. Yellow cake mix.

Both sides. The peanut butter side AND the chocolate side. One box of yellow cake mix.

I didn’t want four dozen cookies, so I didn’t want to use two cake mixes. And Google failed me. No where on the internets could I find a recipe for a chocolate cookie made with a yellow cake mix. I cannot believe I’m the first one to ever do it.

(Pssst…it was easy. I just added some melted chocolate.)

(Pssst again…these cookies were inspired by lots of other versions. Like Maria’s. And Robin’s. And Jessica’s.)

What’s your double-identity secret?

Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Mix Cookies
by Dorothy Kern
Keywords: peanut butter chocolate cookie
6014628
Ingredients (24 cookies)
  • 1 yellow cake mix (I used Betty Crocker Super-Moist)
  • 1/3 cup vegetable oil
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • ½ cup peanut butter
  • 2 ounces semi-sweet chocolate (2 one ounce baking squares), melted and cooled
  • 2 tablespoons brown sugar, divided
  • 2 tablespoons water, divided
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 350°. Line two cookie sheets with parchment paper and set aside.
  2. Using a hand-held mixer, beat cake mix, oil, eggs, and vanilla in a large bowl just until combined. Place half of this mix in a new bowl.
  3. Make the peanut butter cookie side: in the original bowl, add peanut butter, 1 tablespoon brown sugar, and 1 tablespoon water to half of cake mix. Beat until combined. Set aside.
  4. Make the chocolate side: add the melted chocolate to the second bowl, along with the remaining 1 tablespoon brown sugar and 1 tablespoon water. Beat until combined.
  5. Roll 1 tablespoon balls of the peanut butter dough. Add one tablespoon of the chocolate dough to the side of each peanut butter ball. Roll in your hands slightly to make them stick together. Place on cookie sheet and press down slightly. Repeat for the remaining dough. Use a fork to make crisscrosses on each cookie. (The cookies will not spread much.)
  6. Bake 8-10 minutes until the peanut butter side is slightly golden. Cool 2 minutes on cookie sheets, then move to a rack to cool completely.
Powered by Recipage

Have a Linky Party you want me to join? Add it HERE.
These are the fabulous parties I link to each week:
MondayMingle Monday (Add a Pinch), Joy of DessertsCreative Monday (Clairejustineoxox), Mix it Up Monday (Flour Me With Love), Things that make you say mmmm Monday (Cooking with Karyn), Mop it Up Mondays (I should be mopping the floors), Show me what you got (Our Delightful Home). Tuesday2 Maids a Baking (2 Maids a Milking), Tea Party Tuesdays (Sweetology), Mushki Loves My Stuff (Mushki Loves), Totally Tasty Tuesdays (Mandy’s Recipe Box), Talent Show Tuesday (Chef in Training), Trick or Treat Tuesday (Inside BruCrew Life), Let’s Do Brunch (My Sweet & Savory), WednesdayMrs. Fox’s Sweet Party (Mrs. Fox’s Sweets), Cast Party Wednesday (Lady Behind the Curtain), Famous Linkz Par-tay (Made-Famous-By), Bakes with Bizzy (Bizzy Bakes), From Dream to Reality (DIY Dreamer), Whip it Up Wednesday (Crockpot Ladies).  ThursdaySweet Treats Thursday (Something Swanky), Chic-and-Crafty (Frugal Girls), Turning the Table Thursdays (Around My Family Table), Tasty Thursday (The How-To Mommy), Tastetastic Thursday (A little nosh), Sweet Temptations (Talking Dollars and Cents), Taking a Timeout Thursday (Mom on Timeout), Things I’ve Done Thursday (BearRabbitBear), (RHW Recipe Round-Up) The Real Housewives of Riverton, BFF Open House (The Answer is Chocolate), Recipe Round Up (Eat, Pray, Read, Love). FridaySweet Tooth Friday (Alli-n-son), I’m Lovin’ it Fridays (TidyMom), Friday Favorites (Simply Sweet Home), Latest & Greatest Friday (Days of Chalk and Chocolate), Bacon Time, Fusion Friday (Jane Deere Blog), Foodie Friday (Not Your Ordinary Recipes), Dwell on JoyFun Finds Friday (Kitchen Fun with my 3 Sons), Sugar and SpiceSaturdayCountry Mom CooksSweets for a Saturday (Sweet as Sugar Cookies), Seasonal Inspiration (Crumbs and Chaos), You inspire me (Polka Dot Pretties). SundayA Well-Seasoned Life,Sharing Sundays (Everyday Sisters), Strut your Stuff Saturday (Six Sisters’ Stuff), Recipe Party (The Sweet Spot), Seasonal/Occasional Linkys: Moms Crazy CookingSouthern Mom CooksCheap Crafty MommaSusie QTSpringtime Holiday Link Party (Michelle Paige)


2 Responses to “Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookies”

  1. Anne @ Domesblissity posted on March 6, 2012 at 8:14 pm (#)

    I love how you combined the two cookies Dorothy! Thanks for linking this up. You’re just the best baker I know.

    Anne @ domesblissity

    Reply

  2. Kyra posted on June 12, 2012 at 11:26 am (#)

    Hi Dorothy, This is awesome! I would agree with Anne, well done in combining these two cookies. I’ll surely save this recipe. :-) Just a little advice, those kids out there should have a regular check-up in dentist in Melbourne if you could always eat sweets. This could help you to prevent tooth damaged.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *