Homemade Uncrustables Recipe

5 from 1 vote

Skip the grocery store and buy UNCRUSTABLES at home. Make them peanut butter or pizza or with lunchmeat for easy lunch packing!

Prep Time15

Cook Time15

Total Time30

Course: Main Course

Cuisine: American

Servings: sandwiches

Calories: 186kcal

Cost: 8

Preheat your waffle maker to medium-high.
Open the can of biscuits and cut each biscuit in half like you’re making a sandwich. Place about 1 tablespoon of peanut butter on one side of the raw biscuit dough. If desired, top with some jam or honey. Place the top raw half of the biscuit on top and pinch the edges to seal. (The sealing is important or peanut butter will leak all over your waffle maker!)
Depending on the size of your waffle maker, cook one sandwich at a time. (My waffle maker is a standard round size and I make one in the center.) Cook about 2-5 minutes until golden. Time will vary depending on your waffle maker, so just watch the first few and see how long they take.
Cool slightly (or completely) before serving. Store in an airtight container for up to 3 days or freeze for up to one month. To reheat, simply microwave until warm. You can also toast them to make them crunchy. Or just place a frozen sandwich in a lunch box the night before and it’ll be defrosted by lunch the next day!

Preheat your waffle maker to medium-high.
Open the can of biscuits and cut each biscuit in half like you’re making a sandwich. Place about 2 teaspoons of pizza sauce on one side of the raw biscuit dough. If desired, top with some cheese and toppings. Place the top raw half of the biscuit on top and pinch the edges to seal.
Depending on the size of your waffle maker, cook one sandwich at a time. (My waffle maker is a standard round size and I make one in the center.) Cook about 2-5 minutes until golden. Time will vary depending on your waffle maker, so just watch the first few and see how long they take.
Cool slightly (or completely) before serving. Store in an airtight container for up to 3 days or freeze for up to one month. To reheat, simply microwave until warm. You can also toast them to make them crunchy. Or just place a frozen sandwich in a lunch box the night before and it’ll be defrosted by lunch the next day!

These are also great when made with deli turkey or ham and cheese!
Every waffle maker cooks differently so be sure to adjust cook time to suit yours.
Make sure you don’t put too much filling in the center of your Homemade Uncrustables, if you over-fill them, they can break open and ooze on your waffle maker. Put a dollop of the filling in the center. Believe me- it will be enough!
Make sure you fully pinch the sides together on the Uncrustable. The same thing goes! If there are any gaps left, you could have another waffle maker- sticky peanut butter- nightmare
To defrost, simply microwave until warm. You can also toast them to make them crunchy. For an easy pre-made lunch, just place a frozen sandwich in a lunch box the night before, and it’ll be defrosted by lunch the next day!