Chocolate Peanut Pie – an EASY pie filled with peanuts, peanut butter, and chocolate with a gooey center like a pecan pie…but BETTER.
Something totally ironic: on the day I wrote my Toffee Almond Pie post about things that Jordan (and this generation) knows nothing about, Jordan and I watched Clueless. It was (and still is) one of my favorite iconic movies. Fun fact, Alicia Silverstone grew up just a few minutes from me, and went to my rival high school, just a year or two ahead of me.
Anyway, in the course of that movie, I had more wow Jordan has no idea what … is moments. Nothing makes you feel old quite like watching a 90s movie with your tween.
The first little shock was when Cher was talking to her teacher about her grade and said, “Oh my gosh I’m so retarded!” I physically recoiled at the use of the word and promptly launched into a spiel to Jordan, who immediately said “DUH MOM” so I know I’m doing at least something right.
Then Claire pulled out her cell phone, which Jordan called a brick, rightfully so. I had to explain what a pager was (remember pagers? 07734 meant “Hello” and 143 meant “I love you”) and then, the best one: the characters were driving somewhere and pulled out a map to try and figure out where they were going. I told Jordan that’s what we did for maps before Siri and she said…wait for it…”I don’t think I’ve ever seen a paper map.”
I’m just gonna leave that there for y’all to think about.
Meanwhile, this pie. A Chocolate Peanut Pie…it’s like a pecan pie but with peanuts and chocolate chips and peanut butter. Do I need to say anything else?
Let’s get into the anatomy of this pie, which is eerily similar to Pecan Pie and the Toffee Almond Pie from last week. Hey, when something works, why not keep trying it? (Also my motto in clothing: like a shirt? Buy it in every color.)
The filling is a pecan pie-like filling with a corn syrup, butter, and sugar base. I also added some peanut butter in there, because why not? I also added a hefty dose of chocolate chips. Again, because why not? Plus, peanut butter and peanuts makes the pie almost savory in nature, and it needed a little extra sweetness and depth from the chocolate.
I used honey roasted peanuts (I buy them from Trader Joe’s, I love those the most, especially when making peanut butter) but you can use any honey roasted brand or even just regular cocktail or dry-roasted peanuts. Basically, use what you like most, because they’re the major flavor in the pie.
I tasted this pie and immediately put it into the freezer for Thanksgiving. I’m giving it the Mel Ate It tag prematurely, but I guarantee he WILL eat it. (Or, at least a bite, lol.)
If you try ONE pie this holiday, try this one. You won’t be disappointed!
Yield: 8-10 servings
Total Time: 1 hour 30 minutes
Chocolate Peanut Pie - an EASY pie filled with peanuts, peanut butter, and chocolate with a gooey center like a pecan pie.